News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by msh on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:41AM (#10749796)
But its not a lawful subpoena.

What's app is a America n company, so it should only respond to American supoenas. Just as a American judge should not be able to order a Brazilian company to do anything before having it go though the Brazilian courts.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by bjt on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:49AM (#10749813)
A Brazilian company with a presence in the US could absolutely be subject to a US court order without any court in Brazil needing to be involved. You don't get to dodge the laws of a country you're operating in just because your HQ is in some other country.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by msh on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:09AM (#10749891)
But whatsapp don't have a business presence in Brazil.

Just because they have users there is not the same as a business presence.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by hhandoko on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:57AM (#10750036)
Good point.

I suppose this could be a reason why they require a third party (the telcos) to block access to WhatsApp, as they are operating under Brazilian law.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by sdm on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:54AM (#10750027)
Does whatsapp make money from users in Brazil? Then yes, it has a business presence in Brazil.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by msh on Thursday December 17, 2015 @02:16AM (#10750086)
No, that's not the international legal definition for a business presence.

My point is that Brazil should follow legal procedures and have a American judge issue a supena. That's what a MLAT is for.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by lagadu on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:54AM (#10750711)
They are following legal procedures. Brazilian ones, which are the only ones they have to care about. Why would they possibly care in the slightest what American courts have to say?
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by msh on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:29AM (#10750837)
Because they want to enforce their law against a american company.

There are a reason many countries have MLAT's

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by Daishiman on Thursday December 17, 2015 @02:07AM (#10750059)
They have paid users.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by gotchange on Thursday December 17, 2015 @02:36AM (#10750131)
> What's app is a America n company, so it should only respond to American supoenas.

American exceptionalism and supremacy at work.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by msh on Thursday December 17, 2015 @02:44AM (#10750152)
I am not American.

I expect it to work the other way around too. Brazilian companies should not respond to foreign subpoenas unless validated by Brazilian courts.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by gotchange on Thursday December 17, 2015 @03:10AM (#10750206)
Does WhatsApp have any physical presence in Brazil? Did they incorporate any subsidiary there?
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by andreyf on Thursday December 17, 2015 @03:33AM (#10750265)
I don't know, but for the sake of argument, I think it's OK to say no.

If I have a website that is reachable on the internet that hosts a wiki and logs access, does that mean I am doing business in all countries that have internet access? Can any of their courts compel me to disclose visitors from their country? What if I refuse to provide visitor logs, is it OK for them to block my site at the border? What about to order a private teleco to block my site?

I have opinions, but I don't see any obvious answers one way or the other.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by sangnoir on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:38AM (#10750653)
It looks like you want to have your cake and eat it:

> If I have a website that is reachable on the internet that hosts a wiki and logs access, does that mean I am doing business in all countries that have internet access?

I'm guessing your answer to this question is "No". However, since you feel you are not doing business in Brazil (for example),then why complain when Brazil blocks your site? If your answer is "Yes" and you agree that you are in business in all countries, then you should be compelled to follow the laws of the countries whose populace are earning you wealth.

Morally and pragmatically, I feel that if you gain financial benefit from a country, you should follow their laws. If you find the laws unconscionable - refuse to do business there.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by lagadu on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:56AM (#10750715)
> What if I refuse to provide visitor logs, is it OK for them to block my site at the border? What about to order a private teleco to block my site?

That depends exclusively on the laws of the country in question, not on the laws of the country the offender is based on. That's what a sovereign state does, it determines its own rules.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by gotchange on Thursday December 17, 2015 @04:05AM (#10750333)
All the points you raised are legitimate but if WhatsApp or any other company has a physical presence in a certain country, that country authorities have the SOVEREIGN right to uphold the laws of the land and bring transgressors to justice and offering & guaranteeing them a fair trial.