News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by hcarvalhoalves on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:49PM (#10749387)
The news is misrepresenting what is actually happening.

A judge ruled for a 48 hour ban of WhatsApp from telcos to try to coerce WhatsApp into releasing private chat information for an ongoing criminal investigation (wild guess: they want information from politically exposed actors due to the recent corruption investigations). There are precedents, and that's a tactic local judges are using to try to get cooperation from international private companies.

This is the actual fact, but the article is conflating that with Marco Civil and other regulatory attempts that have nothing to do with this particular court ruling.

TL;DR TechCrunch publishes unchecked, alarmist news.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by eduardordm on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:35PM (#10749560)
My wife is a judge and she is not alarmed. She is terrified. We are green card holders and came back to the country 16 years ago. Tonight was the first time we had a conversation about leaving this place for good.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by sounds on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:17AM (#10749916)
Dictator-like behavior has a polarizing effect, which is generally the precursor to large realignments (and possibly violence). On that note: please be careful!

"The more you tighten your grip, the more star systems will slip through your fingers." - Stars Wars Episode 4

Large realignments are the fallout: those who benefit from the dictatorship will be in favor of it. Dictators also have difficulty maintaining their grip on power.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by embik on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:40AM (#10750880)
It's very interesting that we perceive this (public) shutdown as "dictator-like" behaviour while the US uses gag orders, laws and secret courts to force (tech) companies into complying. If you don't want to, you have to shut down your company (see Lavabit). Yet Brasilia is "anti-technology" (sic) because they're not abusing their power in secret.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by sounds on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:35PM (#10756041)
Oh, I'm totally suggesting the US is "dictator-like"--not all US citizens, but the elite. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10748229
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by adenot on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:40PM (#10749584)
I thought if you leave US for more than 3 (?) months you loose your green card status.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by eduardordm on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:45PM (#10749598)
6 months + extensions. A minor effort is required to keep the visa.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by ghshephard on Thursday December 17, 2015 @03:13AM (#10750218)
Be cautious, I had a close friend have their Green Card seized while crossing the border back from Canada into the United States, even though he had documented evidence that he had spent 95% of the previous three years in the United States. He was a consultant, and traveled a lot, but thought he would hang out in Vancouver, BC for a while. Even though he only returned to Vancouver for a few days at a time, before going on the next engagement, and all engagements were in the United States, with a US employer, (And he was a Stanford Graduate) - they seized his GreenCard because his household goods (Mattress/clothing), had left the country more than a couple years ago, and used that as evidence of being away from the United States.

Lesson learned - Sometimes the border staff gets caught up on stupid technicalities. Be aware of them, and don't use common sense.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by briandear on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:33AM (#10750854)
You really only have to set foot in the US once every six months. My wife (now a US citizen) and I would have to make trips to the US every six months to keep her green card alive.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by Shank on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:26AM (#10749740)
The article is about Brazil. He's probably a Brazilian green card holder.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by jzwinck on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:50AM (#10749821)
There is no such thing as a Brazilian green card. Green card is a figure of speech that is mostly used to refer to US permanent residency. Other countries often just call it PR.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by rmc on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:57AM (#10750718)
To further aid confusion, "Green Card" in Europe means a certification from your motor insurance provider that extends motoring insurance to the rest of the "green card countries" (which is basically Europe)
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by benevol on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:02AM (#10749868)
> Other countries often just call it PR.

Very urgently needed PR, if one considers the pace at which the country is turning into an Orwellian total surveillance state (most recent data point: CISA bill hidden in the federal budget bill).

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by dhackner on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:42AM (#10749990)
PR = shorthand for Permanent Resident
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by jsprogrammer on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:19AM (#10750803)
Your wife is a non-citizen judge?
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by lucasnemeth on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:14AM (#10750558)
It's a confidencial investigation, you have no reason to believe it is a politically exposed actor. It can be any sort of investigation, this is highly manipulative. The people who actually created this block wants to make you think it's related to the Lava-Jato, but they are probably doing it due to lobbists from telecom industries.

They could fine facebook, the owner of whatsapp and that have offices in Brazil. It is unrelated to close the service. Has the Brazilian government ever closed Vivo or Tim because it had legal problems? No. They charge fines.

There are precedents, and they were absurd.

All the information on the article regarding Cunha is correct.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by NN88 on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:54PM (#10749627)
I'm not understanding your clarification. It still seems like a ridiculous reason to shut down whatsapp
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by x0x0 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:57AM (#10749852)
Not at all. When companies decline to obey local law, it's reasonable for them to be cut off from operating in that country. Which is what the judge is proposing, temporarily. Probably with longer cutoffs to follow if this doesn't inspire obedience of judicial orders.
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by JoshTriplett on Thursday December 17, 2015 @04:17AM (#10750366)
> When companies decline to obey local law, it's reasonable for them to be cut off from operating in that country.

It's possible. It's only reasonable if the local law is itself reasonable.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by x0x0 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @02:27PM (#10753784)
Obeying duly authorized warrants or subpoenas is very reasonable. It's really not WhatsApp's job or right to pass judgement on the political system of a country. If WhatsApp doesn't like that, they should withdraw their business from Brazil.

And let's be serious; while Brazil may have problems, it's definitely not a dictatorship.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by JoshTriplett on Thursday December 17, 2015 @04:08PM (#10754560)
> Obeying duly authorized warrants or subpoenas is very reasonable.

Depends on the warrant or subpoena and the technology in question. If they have plaintext messages sitting around on a server somewhere, then perhaps they can supply the messages they've irresponsibly given themselves access to. However, WhatsApp claims to provide end-to-end encryption in some (though not all) cases, so they may not have the data in question; if so, a subpoena expecting them to supply it anyway wouldn't be reasonable. A subpoena expecting them to backdoor their client (in general or for a specific user) would not be reasonable.

And that's before getting into the "why" of the individual case, such as whether this has any more merit than the "take down this YouTube video because it embarrasses us" cases that caused Brazil to attempt to block YouTube previously.

Apart from that, a subpoena from a country only has legal meaning to a business with a legal nexus in that country. Providing a service via the Internet does not create a legal nexus in every country in the world.

> If WhatsApp doesn't like that, they should withdraw their business from Brazil.

What business in Brazil? I haven't seen anything in the stories or comments thus far to suggest that they have any legal nexus in Brazil. They have customers all over the world.

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by ank_the_elder on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:54PM (#10749406)
That sounds like a more interesting story - do you have any links to learn more about it? (even if they are in Portuguese) Thanks!
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by hcarvalhoalves on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:55PM (#10749409)
Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by ank_the_elder on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:59PM (#10749431)
(automatic translation, highlight mine)

"[...] Folha learned that justice in São Bernardo do Campo wants WhatsApp stay out of air in the country due to a criminal investigation.

The authorities investigating the case obtained legal authorization for the WhatsApp broke the confidentiality of data exchanged via investigated by the application, but the company did not release the requested information. The blockade would be a reprisal.

In February, a similar case occurred in Piauí, when a judge also ruled WhatsApp lock in Brazil. The aim was to force the company that owns the application to cooperate with state police investigations related to cases of pedophilia.

The decision was suspended by a judge of Piaui Court after analyzing writ of mandamus filed by the telcos. [...]"

Re:Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours by rbanffy on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:29PM (#10749545)
It seems it's related to a narcotraffic investigation, unrelated to corruption scandals, at least for now.