News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Christopher Blizzard: HTML5 video and H.264 – what histor... by kelnos on Monday January 25, 2010 @06:43AM (#1074878)
How is an algorithm proprietary if I can go online to the website of the ITU, a division of the United Nations, and download a copy of the standard and go write my own implementation?

Simple: your understanding of the definition of "proprietary" is incorrect. Keeping a technology secret is a sufficient -- but not necessary -- condition of it being proprietary.

Re:Christopher Blizzard: HTML5 video and H.264 – what histor... by bad_user on Monday January 25, 2010 @07:01AM (#1074895)
Actually this is a case of mixing up "IP" laws ... trade secrets are very different from patents, although patents were partly introduced to encourage companies to open up and to discourage the use of trade secrets.

Anyway ... "proprietary" means just what it says ... "exclusively owned by someone" under a trademark, patent or as a trade secret. So to say that H.264 is proprietary is actually correct.

On the other hand, H.264 is more open than Real Video, since you can get the specs of the format, an implementation is already available to you and the patents are currently reasonably licensed.

That said, the concerns of Mozilla are valid ... we could end up in the same situation as with GIF and MP3 ... although I don't think Theora has any chances to take over since it's technically inferior and H.264 is already accepted as a defacto standard (mostly because of Flash).

Re:Christopher Blizzard: HTML5 video and H.264 – what histor... by mbrubeck on Monday January 25, 2010 @01:46PM (#1075772)
Or it could be that "open" and "proprietary" are two directions on a continuum, rather than binary, mutually exclusive qualities...
Re:Christopher Blizzard: HTML5 video and H.264 – what histor... by kelnos on Monday January 25, 2010 @09:21PM (#1076821)
Well, sure, you could say there are different degrees of "proprietary," but there's really only one "open":

1. Secret spec, patent-encumbered 2. Secret spec, patent-free 3. Open spec, patent-encumbered 4. Open spec, patent-free

You can of course expand that out to include other criteria, but... you get the idea.

I'd argue that #4 is the only one that's really "open," though a case could be made that #3 is both open and proprietary rather than simply proprietary.

Of course there are those who believe #4 isn't really feasible and that some patent somewhere can apply to basically everything... even if the patent holder doesn't know it.