News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:C++14: Transducers by pron on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:16PM (#10746077)
> random multi-millisecond pauses break everything

Then either use a GC that doesn't have multi-millisecond pauses, or make sure your "plain" GC doesn't. Both approaches are used very commonly.

Re:C++14: Transducers by Guvante on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:29PM (#10747496)
It is hard to have a discussion about GC's in the super abstract because object pools are better than GC's and even malloc. Without additional details about what the implementation will look like it is impossible to know the best memory allocation mechanism is.

I was just pointing out that most GC's that are general purpose have 2-3 ms pauses for collection which is a no-go for soft-realtime systems. I did not say that GC's are incompatible with soft-realtime systems.

Re:C++14: Transducers by pron on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:45PM (#10747595)
> because object pools are better than GC's

Object pools and GCs do different things, and you can have object pools in both GCed environments as in manually-managed ones, and they'd work equally the same. But note that you need a very, very good (and far from trivial) object pool to beat a good GC in multithreaded environments.

> I was just pointing out that most GC's that are general purpose have 2-3 ms pauses for collection which is a no-go for soft-realtime systems.

Well, most free ones. If you're writing a soft-realtime system with stricter latency requirements you'll either work harder to avoid the GC or pay for a low-latency one.