Saying that you couldn't afford an item and therefore wouldn't have spent any money on that doesn't really mean you'd never spend any money on that given a free pirated option wasn't available.
The point being we do have the money, and we do can afford it. It's just that, when you can pirate it, you end up spending your money on other things instead. But its not like you'll never have enough money that you'll ever be able to buy one game.
It's interesting to observe the Playstation 3's market, because they've so far done what was unthinkable since way back the times of the PS1: a console you can't pirate.
So I have a loooot of friends that live on Brazil, and that pirated all their PS2 games. And that pirate music and movies too. Some even have an Xbox360 and pirate games on it too. But all of them buy PS3 games. They don't just leave their console there hanging, playing demos, as you'd expect.
People have a limited amount of income, but an insatiable desire to consume. How people deal with this varies from person to person. Though we can generalize it a bit, there is no catch-all generalization that applies to everyone.
In the future though, don't use anecdotes to try and prove a point. 'everyone does X because my friends in Brazil do X' is not a valid argument.
> Saying that you couldn't afford an item and therefore wouldn't have spent any money on that doesn't really mean you'd never spend any money on that given a free pirated option wasn't available.
If I download $3,000 worth of media per month, but I only make $3,500 per month after taxes, how can you posit that I would have bought all $3,000 worth of media where pirating it not an option? If I use the 'pirate market' as a way to consume outside of my income level (i.e. outside of my ability to consume without the 'pirate market') then how could I have purchased all of those things?
To your Brazil example, what were your friends spending that money on when they were pirating PS2 games or did their income level suddenly jump when the PS3 came out?
As for the income/worth of consumed media for month, I surely don't believe the amount of lost sales or whatever companies claim is exactly the amount of consumed media. That's false as you clearly illustrate. It means people would consume less media, within their means.
All those friends of mine, would the xbox 360 not have pirated games, would also have bought original games. They wouldn't just let it there, sitting. Would they buy every each of their pirated games? of course not.
So my thought process is not like "if there weren't pirated media, people'd pay for all they consumed as pirated items", but rather "weren't there pirated media, people would either consume original media, or do something else, and we can't tell that for sure". And therefore asserting that people who pirate stuff "would have never bought that anyway" is wrong.
Besides. As many companies who have dropped DRM have found, many pirates are simply waiting for an unencumbered form of what they want. If the only legitimate porsche seller is selling half-crushed cars, and there's a perfect-quality one sitting next door with the keys in the ignition and a sign that says "free to a good home", is it even ethical to buy the crap one? (that said, all "would you steal a porsche" arguments are straw man arguments anyway)
Ah, not if it's a DRM'd PC game. Many allow it, but try doing that with a Steam game. You're stuck with the often-inaccurate demo version of the game. And if you're talking about a console game, where do you go and who do you know to find all games you may be interested in? I generally have less than 10% success rate when visiting rental places, and that's not including foreign language titles that aren't available anywhere here.
Reviews are extremely poor substitutes for a good demo, in the same way that arm-chair theorizing is a poor substitute for field experience. And don't feed me bullshit about movie trailers being in any way a good measurement of what the movie will be like. Does reading a book really get you to understand what army life is like? To make matters worse, good demos are hard to come by, as most are relatively crippled compared to what you'd be buying (games and regular apps). If the demo doesn't demonstrate why I'd want it, or implies things that aren't true, I claim false advertising. And this is assuming there even is a demo version.
Though, look at how spoiled we've become by piracy. Now, we say we'd only buy something if we the exact same experience as we'll have with the final product. A demo is sometimes far from the game experience? yep. Movie trailers are bullshit? Sometimes, yes they are! Movie synopsis then? Even more!
Now, think about all the other things you buy. You can't really go to a car shop and say: "Hi. I'm looking for a car to cross the us. So, in order for it to be really like my final experience, I'll need to borrow it for at least a week.". Or like, "Hi, I want to try a Mac. Of course the factory Mac doesnt' help me much, so I'll borrow it for a day to install emacs/vi, some terminal scripts, quicksilver and see if it suits me well". The list goes on.
Specially with all the other non-pirated items, we have to make a decision about the buying the final product before we've had access to the final product. It's really up to the producer which means he'll provide you, as a sales mechanism, to try his product before you make your buying decision.
Not being able to have the full experience before you buy, specially with some kinds of products (some books, some games, most movies) is critical to selling it. It's not the consumer's right to take by force the final experience from the producer to make a buying decision.
I rented three games in a row from the local hollywood video for my 360 that were unplayable in some way. One was 'ringed' by another user, another was scratched just enough to lock up after the entry video and the third didn't boot at all. After the third trip back down the block to tell them 'hey this doesn't play either' I just downloaded the game and played it on my PC.
Needless to say, I haven't tried renting a game again.
Wait, you're saying 'only some of them will be paid for', even though you've been convinced all the products are 'a necessity'. A more succinct way of putting this, that I believe loses none of the intended meaning, is 'I want I want I want.' Of course, this behaviour is not to be blamed on you, poor consumer, for you live in an awful society which has bombarded -- yes, bombarded -- you with vile and shrill marketing in order to trick you into thinking you need it. The horror, the horror!
That may be. But if the consumer consumes the product without paying because they couldn't afford it in the first place, can you really say that you lost money on that? If they didn't have the money to buy it in the first place, how could they have given you money for it if piracy wasn't an option?
The real cause of piracy (other than availability) is the over-saturation of media markets that we have. Example: If I want to buy a new video game for $60, that's maybe 4 or 5 CDs that I can't buy, so I download those CDs instead.
I know that some people will call it naive, but we live in a society where we are bombarded by marketing in which everyone tries to shout the loudest or find the best way to subtly convince you that you need their product (i.e. you won't be cool unless you have X). But we are now in a marketplace where the consumer can choose to pay for X and pirate Y instead of just deciding to (exclusively) buy X or Y. So it comes down to this: If everyone is able to convince me that their product is a necessity, then I'll end up acquiring all of those products, but only some of them will be paid for.
Note: I'm using a hypothetical 'me/I' in this explantion.