Re:Facewatch 'thief recognition' CCTV on trial in UK stores
by Retric on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:03AM
(#10744631)
So, if you’re looking for 1% of a total population your false positive rate before human intervention is 99%. That's not useful for automated systems.
Further, identical twins are going to show an image that would fool human verification making this questionable for many tasks even with human supervision.
PS: Almost 1% of the population has an identical twin. (% of births is lower, but you get 2 twins.)
Re:Facewatch 'thief recognition' CCTV on trial in UK stores
by bsenftner on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:15AM
(#10744707)
There is only one true match. So the system will always be generating false positives. This technology is not an authority, but a filter. Yes, identical twins will both be identified if they are both in the system and no additional biometric measures are included. Identical twins still have different retina, and due to lifestyles identical twins beyond age 30 can be distinguished apart fairly easily.
Re:Facewatch 'thief recognition' CCTV on trial in UK stores
by rmc on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:25AM
(#10744783)
What's the "industry" you speak of? This article is suggesting this be used by minimum wage (or below[1]) workers in shops, bars and restaurants. How well do you think your industries norms will be adhered to?
[1] UK tried (is trying?) a "you must work for free in what would be a minimum wage job in a high street shop" scheme. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-24742499
The issue I find with FR is people expecting it to be some super technology, gleaming significant information from a dust spec. Its not like that. And the media is playing it up with unrealistic descriptions. Remember the original DOOM and it's quality of graphics? That is where FR is now. We've got a ways before the journalist hype is close to reality. And the mature technology will not be FR, but a comprehensive multiple biometric measuring system capturing far more than someone's face.