News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Piracy is a Market Correction. by anamax on Sunday January 24, 2010 @11:48PM (#1074437)
> it's also about being able to get a product in the form and through the channel that a consumer wants

Why do consumers have the right to their choice of form, channel and price?

If the seller is unwilling to provide as the consumer prefers, where does the consumer get the right to force the producer's hand?

What's wrong with "if the buyer and seller don't agree on terms, the deal doesn't happen"?

Re:Piracy is a Market Correction. by ewjordan on Monday January 25, 2010 @06:25AM (#1074862)
Why do consumers have the right to their choice of form, channel and price?

They don't have any particular "right" to these choices.

But that doesn't mean the choices disappear. And it also doesn't mean that real value is not created by offering them, even if it's done illegally: the Pirate Bay has probably created more real value in this world than most startups could ever dream of. It doesn't matter that it's ethics are questionable.

What's wrong with "if the buyer and seller don't agree on terms, the deal doesn't happen"?

Nothing at all, that's exactly what happens a lot of the time.

With most digital media it just so happens that there are plenty of illegal "sellers" that are willing to step in with terms that are more suitable to the buyer.

It may not be legal or "right", but it's pretty damn efficient.

Re:Piracy is a Market Correction. by nettdata on Monday January 25, 2010 @12:43AM (#1074523)
Welcome to the current overly-developed sense of self-entitlement that a lot of people have these days.

Everyone is owed everything with nothing in return.

Re:Piracy is a Market Correction. by pyre on Monday January 25, 2010 @01:21AM (#1074580)
Not necessarily. There are a lot of people that are just compulsive hoarders, but their hoarding is directed at digital 'items.'

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsive_hoarding

Comparatively, there are compulsive hoarders of physical items that have their house filled to the brim with items that they have purchased, or run up huge amounts of debt acquiring.

Re:Piracy is a Market Correction. by nfnaaron on Sunday January 24, 2010 @11:56PM (#1074452)
"Why do consumers have the right to their choice of form, channel and price?"

I'm not saying they have that right, not beyond deciding to buy or not. I'm pointing out that some consumers do try to appropriate that right, and that's one indication of demand.

Re:Piracy is a Market Correction. by tptacek on Monday January 25, 2010 @12:08AM (#1074470)
It is also an indication of the demand for car stereos when someone cinderblocks my window and rips the stereo out of the dash.