News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:23AM (#10743560)
It's a bit sad to see LibreOffice struggling to maintain relevance when the market it tried to address suddenly became [nearly nonexistent] irrelevant.

It reminds me of all those hundreds of early 20th century battleships that suddenly became completely irrelevant when the Dreadnought came by.

[Edit: replaced nearly nonexistent with irrelevant to make my point clearer]

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by coldtea on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:54AM (#10743672)
>It's a bit sad to see LibreOffice struggling to maintain relevance when the market it tried to address suddenly became nearly nonexistent.

If you mean that we've moved from desktop office apps to cloud-based Office apps that's absolutely not true.

The numbers I've seen for Google Docs etc are insignificant compared to office workers using MS Office and the rest. People who think Cloud docs have "won" apparently don't share the sames experiences with 99% of office workers in enterprise/businesses/governments etc.

In startup-land and small web businesses yes, cloud docs do well, but those are insignificant numbers-wise to the millions upon millions of classic office workers.

LibreOffice might be irrelevant, but that's because not many care for a free/open source office suite that's not MS Office, not because we've moved to Cloud documents.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by scholia on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:14AM (#10743757)
This is true. However, the cloud is part of Office 365's ecosystem play. You get the full-strength Office programs installed locally (Windows and Mac), plus the ability to work in the cloud, plus the mobile apps for Windows, iOS and Android.

Even if "99% of office workers in enterprise/businesses/governments etc" do their work on the desktop, there's still some appeal to being able to get what you want where you want it. This is where LibreOffice is trailing badly (as is Google Docs).

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by workitout on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:57AM (#10744241)
>> there's still some appeal to being able to get what you want where you want it

That implies most companies are willing to trust their business secrets to the cloud. That isn't what I see happening, not in medium sized business or enterprises.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by scholia on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:22PM (#10747815)
Agreed, up to a point. But a lot of companies are already using hosted email, and a lot have signed up for Office 365 and/or Google Docs....

https://cloud.google.com/customers/ https://products.office.com/en-us/business/office-365-custom...

Quite a lot use salesforce.com and other services. It isn't the majority, but the cloud business is big and it's growing fast.

http://www.computerworld.com/article/2974016/enterprise-appl...

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:32AM (#10743823)
Do you believe that will be the same 10 years from now? 15? It takes a lot of time to change an installed base, but that ship has sailed already.
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by aikah on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:32AM (#10744106)
> Do you believe that will be the same 10 years from now? 15? It takes a lot of time to change an installed base, but that ship has sailed already.

Try working with a 200 MB document in Google Docs or Onedrive .Do you really think people that have to work 8 hours a day on such documents can afford a web app being slow and unresponsive ? There will always be a place for native apps. Yes the web is getting better, but it certainly didn't deliver its promise when it comes to replacing desktop apps, or PC games or whatever.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:47AM (#10744174)
Oh yeah, there will always be a place. But that's not what really matters, but the size of that place. Cloud-based productivity systems can replace native apps for over 90% of all corporate functions (marketing, HR, sales, etc.).

Sure, you'll still need native systems for a few heavy functions (finance will keep on using excel for quite a while), but most of the use cases don't need a full-sized productivity suite.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by coldtea on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:53AM (#10745021)
>Oh yeah, there will always be a place. But that's not what really matters, but the size of that place. Cloud-based productivity systems can replace native apps for over 90% of all corporate functions (marketing, HR, sales, etc.).

Or that's what those that built them think.

Then they found out performance and latency make it a non starter, and those "10% of features" that people use from Word, Powerpoint etc, are not the same 10% of everybody, so minimal web based replacements wont cut it.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by SwellJoe on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @12:51PM (#10745908)
I haven't used a desktop document or spreadsheet in years. The argument that a couple of missing features, or ones that are somewhat sluggish over a bad network connection, will prevent widespread adoption of cloud-based products is completely ignoring the huge benefits of cloud-based systems.

In short: Calling Google docs a "non-starter" seems like a difficult position to defend. It's already in use by millions of people, daily, and growth is high. There are plenty of folks, including businesses, who have opted not to install MS Office and instead use Docs for everything. Sure, there are plenty of situations where that doesn't work, but as the "web as a platform" advances, and as office products on the web advance, the reasons for sticking with installed apps will continue to decline.

There will continue to be need for installed applications for heavy users for a long time to come (nobody is suggesting serious video or audio editing online, yet, but image editing is already reasonably do-able). Text-based and number-based documents? Those are easy. The very first personal computers could do them pretty well (Visicalc and WordStar, among others), and the web as a platform is vastly more powerful than the Apple II, C64, or IBM PC, that ran those products. And, they're also very easy to work on over very slow connections; you download the whole doc and check in changes in the background. Effectively making all the work happen on the client-side. No big deal.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by jfim on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:28PM (#10747065)
It's a non starter in many use cases. There's no support for ODBC so you can't connect your spreadsheet to the internal BI servers, conditional formatting is really weak in Google sheets (no data bars, etc.), you can't have spreadsheets that refer to other spreadsheets, docs has awful formatting options, etc.

It's just the same thing as comparing nano to emacs/vim. Sure, they both superficially edit text, but that's where the comparison ends.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by SwellJoe on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:47PM (#10747203)
OK, so it's not competitive for some use cases today. Nothing prevents implementation of any of those features, or an evolution away from needing those specific features and replacing them with other features. You mention ODBC, which is a cool feature for some folks, but desktop spreadsheets can't readily hook up to a form on the web, which Google docs can. There are powerful new functionalities provided by web-based apps, and in many cases, those new functionalities trump the old ones.

To argue that what is true today will remain true effectively forever is to ignore the entire history of computing. Desktop applications won't win in the end. Every time a credible web-based alternative has arisen, it has won and destroyed the old way of doing things. So much so that we forget old ways even existed. In a decade I'll be surprised if there is still a desktop version of Office even still in development. There will be web-based versions that work without Internet access, but there won't be a version you "install" on your client machine. I'd bet it'll be sooner for most people, but there will remain outliers for several years beyond which there is a good business case for sticking with Office installed on each users machine.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by jfim on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:39PM (#10749577)
Nothing prevents implementation of any of those features, other than the fact that browser platforms don't allow some basic features to work.

Copy paste? No, not without Flash. Calendar notifications that work when the browser is closed? Custom fonts? Vertical text? Software that doesn't rot? Accurate page layouts?

If these new functionalities were so good and browser integrations were so powerful, then phones wouldn't need app stores, GMail/Google Docs wouldn't have a mobile application, etc. I'm more than ready to bet that in a decade, there will still be a desktop version of Office.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by SwellJoe on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:11AM (#10749679)
"Copy paste? No, not without Flash."

What? Of course copy paste works, even with formatting. Or, at least it does on my machine. Spreadsheets are trickier, but there are ways to override the context menu to make it do-able. I assume Google docs can already do it. Haven't tried it specifically, but I don't remember not being able to...so pretty sure I have copied and pasted within a docs spreadsheet.

"Calendar notifications that work when the browser is closed?"

Why would your browser be closed? This is the future we're talking about. Your desktop and everything else will be in your browser. That's like complaining that notifications don't work when your computer is unplugged.

"Custom fonts? Vertical text?"

Already possible and covered by standards. Are you using IE10, or something?

"Software that doesn't rot?"

Hahahah. Funny. How's Visual Basic written ten years ago holding up on Win 10? Sure, it probably runs, but nobody wants to use it. Platforms evolve. Standards compliant HTML and JavaScript written ten years ago is still functional. What do you believe is uniquely prone to "rot" about the web platform?

All of the app stores have hundreds of apps built on web technologies. Google has a mobile version, but does not have a desktop version. In fact, GMail (and moreso, Inbox) are much better evidence for the case I'm making (that the web will devour almost every class of software in a decade) than the case you're making (that office software like Word and Excel are uniquely immune to being devoured). Inbox is a better mail client than Outlook. And Docs will become a better doc suite than Office...or somebody else will build one that is (might even be Microsoft that builds it...if they're smart, it will be).

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by scholia on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:59PM (#10748045)
> Sure, there are plenty of situations where that doesn't work, but as the "web as a platform" advances, and as office products on the web advance, the reasons for sticking with installed apps will continue to decline.

This is true, but it doesn't have to be one or the other. Office 365 lets you have full-strength desktop programs as well as web apps and smartphone apps, at one low price.

This may be why Office 365 seems to be growing faster than Google Docs, and why it has overtaken it, according to one survey. (1)

Of course, there are other considerations. First, most real businesses need something much more powerful than today's web apps. Second, Microsoft Office is a programmable platform with a huge range of third-party add-ons. Third, a lot of big companies have two decades of Office programming and Office documents. Even if they really want to move everything to the cloud, they're going to run hybrid and in-house cloud systems for a long time....

(1) http://www.computerworld.com/article/2974016/enterprise-appl...

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:50AM (#10744190)
You could just as easily use a lightweight native productivity suite. None of the arguments you're making imply web-based solutions in of themselves.
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @09:08AM (#10744299)
I'm not implying the web-based solutions are the only which will exist in the productivity suite market. But they are where the mass market is moving to. Native suites will still exist in niche cases, but they will have a very hard time competing with lightweight, low-overhead web-based suites.
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by coldtea on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @10:54AM (#10745035)
>I'm not implying the web-based solutions are the only which will exist in the productivity suite market. But they are where the mass market is moving to.

Any actual evidence for this in the Office suite space? Because I don't see it happening at all. It was an empty promise of 5-6 years ago, same as "Year of the Linux desktop" never came to be.

For mail and collaboration (Slack, Jira, Asana etc), sure, web solutions will prevail. After all those things are all about the social, collaborative features the web brings to the table.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by bkor on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:08PM (#10746023)
What's your experience based upon?

Sales and marketing are often heavy Excel users from what I've seen. Even with the uptake of Salesforce (seems to be used more and more), you still have lots of Excel users. HR is usually a tiny bit of the company so I don't really find that interesting.

I mostly see a mix of things at best.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:16AM (#10744031)
In tech, all things old are new again every 10 years or so. You can't ever say "that ship has sailed."
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:53AM (#10744212)
Sure you can, concepts survive, but the companies that implemented them in a certain way don't. Things will move to the server and back probably an endless number of times in the future, and each time, a large score of companies will become irrelevant and die off.

Take pagers, the concept (delivering messages) still exists, but the mass market for dedicated, dumb message receivers disappeared a long time ago, leaving only a few niches.

Any company doing a mass-market, native-only, offline-only office productivity suite is bound to fade into oblivion, unless it changes. And that's the point of my original post, LibreOffice is going exactly through that.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by RottenHuman on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:04AM (#10743965)
> replaced nearly nonexistent with irrelevant to make my point clearer

I'm afraid your point is still not clear. What's your metric for declaring a market irrelevant?

A conventional office suite is still the solution which is overwhelmingly dominating the market. Maybe look outside your own bubble and bias. A lot of business will never give away there confidential documents in the hands of third party cloud hosts. (which is the sane approach). So what's your criteria for calling that niche, irrelevant or even non-existent?

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:02AM (#10745096)
When all the major players are switching to a different market. Sure, the installed base is still conventional office suites, but that's like saying that the car market is still gas-based even if all new cars sold are electrical (hypothetical situation).

http://www.winbeta.org/news/office-365-overtakes-google-apps... Bitglass also found that the share of companies using a cloud application for their productivity suite rose from 28% last year to 48% this year. Their report shows that Microsoft has successfully capitalized on the growth in cloud based productivity suite adoption rates to take the lead from Google.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by jacquesm on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:37AM (#10743607)
> It's a bit sad to see LibreOffice struggling to maintain relevance when the market it tried to address suddenly became nearly nonexistent.

It works just fine for me and I'm not going anywhere for now so this little part of the 'market' will be around for a while.

The ability to own and administer your files is severely under-rated.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:41AM (#10743620)
Oh yes, there will always be a very small niche market for almost any piece of technology. Open source projects never die, they just linger forever on the edges of oblivion.

> The ability to own and administer your files is severely under-rated.

Or severely over-rated depending who you ask :)

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by jacquesm on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:46AM (#10743637)
> Or severely over-rated depending who you ask :)

Give it some time.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by andrepd on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:58AM (#10743690)
>the market it tried to address suddenly became nearly nonexistent

Can you give something to back the claim?

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:42AM (#10743868)
I edited my post, my point was that the market for pure offline office productivity suites has become irrelevant, since the competition now is between a pure cloud-based service and a mix of offline and cloud based service :)
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by RottenHuman on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:10AM (#10743992)
And why should LibreOffice not be able to integrate a "cloud service" into their suite?

The extension interface of Libre Office even lets me think that this would be technically a triviality to integrate.

Maybe with an open standard instead of a propriety and closed eco system,

with the freedom to choose whom you trust with your data, or to host it yourself.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:59AM (#10744248)
Oh, they can, no doubt about that. And that's what the post is about, trying to stay relevant in a changing market. But it adds a lot of complexity, since it switches from a product to a service.
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by downtide on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:08AM (#10743732)
Which market are you referring to?

I still crave for a really nice word processor, spreadsheet, and easy database app (in the style of Access). I've always found *Office a bit rough around the edges.

My partner recently brought home an iPad from work. Word failed to play well with other (MS Word) Office documents, so file exchange and formats are still a complete pain in the neck. I will be using plain text until something better comes along.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by davidgerard on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:05PM (#10747325)
We use Google Docs at work.

The word processor and spreadsheet are rudimentary and the OOXML compatibility is terrible.

My favourite new feature in LibreOffice is the Google Drive integration (a first-class feature in LO 5.1). Because sometimes I need a proper bloody word processor or to read an OOXML doc someone's sent me.

LO Online will be proper LO at the back end, so will be that word processor etc.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:43AM (#10743871)
I think we can all agree that you're not representative of the market, and to be honest, I'd guess (with no data to back it up) that the majority of readers here aren't as well.
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by downtide on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:18AM (#10744035)
I wouldn't say I was representative of the market. But I would like a good product. How do you define the market?
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by ucaetano on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:57AM (#10744239)
People who would like a product/service and are willing to pay enough (in the required scale) for that product/service to exist.

The current core market for office productivity suites are business, followed by consumer. And I'd bet only a very small minority of those are sticking with plain text files until something better comes along.

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by scholia on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:16AM (#10743764)
>I will be using plain text until something better comes along.

Didn't RTF coma along a couple of decades ago?

Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by downtide on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:24AM (#10744062)
I should rephrase that then. The plain text is very portable. And easier to edit and read than RTF. That's not to say that there aren't good RTF editors out there. Even HTML is more readable.
Re:LibreOffice as a service offers alternative to Google Doc... by scholia on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:31PM (#10747874)
Depends what you want to do. RTF can handle the presentation needs of most simple documents, and most word processors can edit RTF files, including WordPad and TextEdit. It's also very easy to convert RTF to plain text.....