Re:Year one: progress in the fight against Unwanted Software
by benplumley on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:02AM
(#10730981)
That's not under Google's control, it's under the OEM's or (in the US) the carrier. A phone bought directly from Google (the Nexus line, Google Play edition, etc) doesn't have crapware of any kind unless you extend the definition to any app you don't personally use.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Year one: progress in the fight against Unwanted Software
by mahouse on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:21AM
(#10731084)
Of course it's under Google's control. "If you don't remove that crapware we don't allow you to bundle the Play Store with that phone".
Re:Year one: progress in the fight against Unwanted Software
by shinratdr on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:31AM
(#10731148)
This simply isn't true. The Skyhook trial proved definitively that Google has the power to dictate what OEMs that ship the Google Apps suite include on their phones. Problem is, they've only ever used that ability to push their own products and services.
Re:Year one: progress in the fight against Unwanted Software
by ocdtrekkie on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:43AM
(#10731213)
There's two categories of bloatware, both of which Google can control:
- Google's bloatware. Google insists OEMs include like 20 Google services on every phone. Get rid of it. All of it. People want the Play Store, and if they want any other Google service, they can download it themselves.
- Third party bloatware. Google places dozens of branding and so-called 'quality' restrictions on how Android is shipped. At the very least, all pre-installed software should be uninstallable, and that's a reasonable consumer protection they could insist upon in the MADA. As another commenter said though, Google only uses the MADA to protect it's illegal monopoly, not to protect consumers.
Re:Year one: progress in the fight against Unwanted Software
by Brotkrumen on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:57AM
(#10731291)
Google only contols manufacturers as far as they want to ship google playstore. Android itself is gpl and apache license, so oems could just roll it themselves or go to a group such as cyanogenmod if google gets too restrictive.
Re:Year one: progress in the fight against Unwanted Software
by ocdtrekkie on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:05AM
(#10731341)
That's really not shockingly relevant. It's nearly impossible to sell a successful Android product without the Play Store. If it was, most companies would already be doing it to avoid Google's bloatware.