Re:Wooden high-rises change city skylines as builders ditch ...
by kibwen on Sunday December 13, 2015 @04:21PM
(#10728002)
An earthquake that shuts off water to a whole city seems just as liable to render uninhabitable all those concrete buildings (assuming they don't outright collapse). Wooden structures seem more likely than concrete to survive the initial quake, even if they're less likely to survive the resultant fires, so it may be a wash in the end.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Wooden high-rises change city skylines as builders ditch ...
by vlehto on Sunday December 13, 2015 @04:34PM
(#10728052)
Historically the fires have been often even more hazardous than the quakes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1906_San_Francisco_earthquake#...
Something like 30% wood might be the best. But it creates interesting problem, who gets to live in a wooden building? Who gets to build one?
Re:Wooden high-rises change city skylines as builders ditch ...
by kibwen on Sunday December 13, 2015 @05:01PM
(#10728163)
I trust that the vast majority of the destruction in the aftermath of the earthquake was caused by fire, but what I'm curious about is the death toll of the fires themselves, which I don't see in the article. The reason that it matters is because an earthquake can easily cause structural damage to a building that leaves it standing but renders it uninhabitable, forcing you to demolish it anyway. Even structures that are specifically built to withstand earthquakes aren't necessarily safe to occupy after the quake. From this (simplistic) perspective, wood is no worse than concrete because either way you'll be forced to rebuild the vast majority of the city after the big one hits.
Re:Wooden high-rises change city skylines as builders ditch ...
by vlehto on Sunday December 13, 2015 @05:42PM
(#10728286)
You have good points. My only counter point is that rescuing people from ruble is easier if there are not much fires around.