Re:The Moral Failure of Computer Scientists
by r-w on Saturday December 12, 2015 @01:24PM
(#10723585)
I wish this article were more particular about what cryptologists are doing wrong? What exactly could they have done instead? Without that info, it just seems like pointing a finger at cryptologists and saying, “This is your job! Do something!”
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Moral Failure of Computer Scientists
by cdavidcash on Saturday December 12, 2015 @01:33PM
(#10723615)
Rogaway wrote an companion essay for his invited talk that is rather accessible: http://web.cs.ucdavis.edu/~rogaway/papers/moral-fn.pdf
Re:The Moral Failure of Computer Scientists
by Ar-Curunir on Saturday December 12, 2015 @09:26PM
(#10725156)
Modern academic cryptographers have veered off into a land of purely theoretical constructs. Now I love the cool theory we have in crypto, but it's sad that despite all this cool theory, very little of it becomes applicable in building practical privacy-preserving systems.
Rogaway, is a famed academic cryptographer, student of Silvio Micali, who basically founded modern academic cryptography. He is highly respected within the crypto community, so his words hold a lot of weight, and my interactions with crypto professors indicates that they agree with what he says.
Re:The Moral Failure of Computer Scientists
by tptacek on Saturday December 12, 2015 @04:30PM
(#10724236)
That's probably not a fair criticism. This is reporting about an extremely famous cryptographer pointing his finger at other cryptographers.
Here's more about it:
Re:The Moral Failure of Computer Scientists
by waqf on Saturday December 12, 2015 @04:59PM
(#10724326)
Thanks for that pointer. I agree with GP's criticism, though, at least the way the article is written. I was trying to understand it through the lens of the nuclear analogy and failing drastically, because whereas those scientists were developing PRO-nuclear technology, these ones are (a priori, to first order) developing ANTI-surveillance technology.
Re:The Moral Failure of Computer Scientists
by ethbro on Saturday December 12, 2015 @09:35PM
(#10725176)
The nuclear analogy is a little odd, given that one of the reasons we don't have even more nuclear weapons / more states with nuclear weapons / nuclear weapons out in the wild is not technological... but because of international treaties and enforcement.