News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by Hexstream on Saturday January 23, 2010 @11:32AM (#1071998)
"- But I could just download gst-plugins-ugly and I'd be OK. - That's a selfish attitude. Everyone should be able to browse the Web with a free software stack without having to jump through arcane hoops to download and install software (whose use is legally questionable)."

I'll tell you what's selfish: going out of your way to cripple the experience of your users just so your extremist ideological views can prevail (and they won't anyway).

I don't think the deliberate weakening of the #1 open-source browser over such trivial matters is a win either, ideological or otherwise.

I love Firefox and I hope this sorry state of affairs will be quickly resolved sensibly before irrecoverable damage has been done.

</opiniated>

Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by bad_user on Saturday January 23, 2010 @01:53PM (#1072217)
Everybody's selfish, but Mozilla is also short-sighted ... they cannot and will not be able to have an influence on the defacto standards for codecs if they aren't popular enough.

This was the right time to really push for HTML5 and standards ... to push Flash/Silverlight/Quicktime out of the way. Safari, Chrome, Opera and Firefox combined have enough market-share to do that.

But no ... they take the same stance as Linux distros, all proprietary stuff is evil, ban it all. Unfortunately, while they have a point (H264 is not safe) ... they'll just lose users to Chrome or Safari.

Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by nzmsv on Saturday January 23, 2010 @02:50PM (#1072304)
This is exactly how we ended up with things like ActiveX and Flash in the first place. It's not enough to make things just work today. Mozilla is right to be thinking about what happens a few years down the road.

Mozilla has enough market share to make it relevant to web developers. Who will have to learn about the issue, and support Firefox. The users don't matter nearly as much.

Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by bad_user on Saturday January 23, 2010 @05:42PM (#1072552)
> This is exactly how we ended up with things like ActiveX and Flash in the first place.

No, and I really don't see the resemblance. We ended up with ActiveX, Flash and Java (you forgot about it) in the first place, because there was no other way to get around the browser's limitations.

In fact it's quite the opposite ... wasn't XmlHttpRequest implemented first as an ActiveX object in IExplorer 5? Or do you think some standards body magically came up with it and everyone was happy?

H264 is the current standard for video, with lots of tools and lots of momentum ... in order to replace it you'll have to put a whole lot more on the table than ideology.

Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by ZeroGravitas on Saturday January 23, 2010 @04:21PM (#1072431)
Talking of ActiveX, apparently Mozilla had code to support that and made the ideological decision not to. That worked out well for everyone.
Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by halo on Saturday January 23, 2010 @12:13PM (#1072063)
It's interesting to draw an analogy between this and Apple's lack of support for Flash, especially given the lack of support for the prior but the large amount of support for the latter on here.

I can only conclude you think it's equally selfish for Apple to cripple the experience of their users so their ideological views can prevail (and that they won't anyway).

I can also conclude that you don't think that the deliberate weakening of the #1 smartphone browser over such trivial matters is a win either, ideological or otherwise.

Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by alextgordon on Saturday January 23, 2010 @12:22PM (#1072078)
That's not quite a fair analogy. If Apple allowed Flash on the iPhone, it would have real consequences: lower battery life, higher RAM usage. I don't doubt for a minute that there's an ideological component as well - Apple want to see Flash gone. But at least that decision is based on technological problems with Flash.

On the other hand, if Firefox were to support OS H.264 decoders, it would harm nothing but Mozilla's ideologies.

Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by middayc on Saturday January 23, 2010 @04:23PM (#1072433)
If in couple of years all web clients support only patented video codecs (which will happen if Mozilla doesn't succed here). Imagine doing a video startup or anything related to video that isn't irrelevant then.
Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by halo on Saturday January 23, 2010 @12:48PM (#1072133)
The technical problems are trivially overcome by requiring the user to press a button to activate Flash and/or providing an option, so that's pretty much moot.
Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by evgen on Sunday January 24, 2010 @12:43AM (#1073034)
Pressing a button does not change the abysmal performance of Flash on a Mac, why would one expect it to change this problem on a iPhone? The positions being taken by Mozilla and Apple in these cases are similar, but Apple's technical justification has merit while Mozilla's political stance has no technical merit to hide behind.
Re:Video, Freedom And Mozilla by middayc on Sunday January 24, 2010 @06:46AM (#1073219)
I have flash lite on my shitty noname nokia I bought for 20 eur, I can play youtube videos on webpages, and it even played some flash games I made with HaXe. I am certain iPhone has much better cpu than this ordinary phone, so I don't see technical merits in apple's decision but exclusiveness and closing itself in walled garden.

same for java btw..