Re:Legal analysis of the personhood granted to corporations
by azzleandre on Saturday January 23, 2010 @08:14AM
(#1071761)
You're right. I have to agree with you on that. And I may haven't been clear enough, about what my problem is with awarding personhood to corporations.
I think that you can't judge corporations the way you can judge humans. You have to apply a different "personhood" to a company, since corporations are not natural. They don't consist of what a human being consists, but of what human beings contributed to that consistence.
Re:Legal analysis of the personhood granted to corporations
by ugh on Saturday January 23, 2010 @10:04AM
(#1071880)
Yes, I think they are different. Personhood is a useful concept but – I guess I’ll have to agree with you – only to a point. I would argue that corporations should have rights, yet not necessarily always the same ones persons have. It’s quite obviously complicated :)
You need a publisher, you need an ISP. The government might very well grant you freedom of speech. If they can limit the rights of corporations however they damn well please that freedom of speech is not worth very much.
Corporations are how humans do stuff. Corporations are important. Corporations have to be protected from the government.