Re:How Airplanes Fly: A Physical Description of Lift (1999)
by jessaustin on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:53PM
(#10708969)
Frankly I've never understood how the Bernoulli explanation became so widespread. Anyone who has held her hand out a car window has learned everything qualitative one can know about airfoils. It's almost as though someone were trying so hard to find a non-intuitive model that he fooled himself that his model actually explained anything.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How Airplanes Fly: A Physical Description of Lift (1999)
by burnte on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:38AM
(#10709213)
It's fairly well accepted that the Bernoulli principle is not the only mechanism of lift today, but it IS a real mechanism, and part of what creates lift in most airfoils, is entirely responsible for technologies such as Bernoulli disk drives, and a minuscule factor in things like kites and paper planes (and your hand out the window).
Re:How Airplanes Fly: A Physical Description of Lift (1999)
by nether on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:01AM
(#10709287)
The thing is a lot of people have taken "Bernoulli" to mean "equal time of passage" (a completely made-up, non-physical phenomenon) rather than the quite valid Bernoulli equation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernoulli%27s_principle#Incomp.... In reality Bernoulli, Newton, and Kutta are just multiple correct abstractions for turning the flow.
Re:How Airplanes Fly: A Physical Description of Lift (1999)
by jessaustin on Thursday December 10, 2015 @09:01AM
(#10710597)
You're right, of course. However, the various explanations are suited to different audiences. An aerospace engineer knows everything she needs to know about all of these tools, so she just uses whatever is best suited to a particular situation. For explanation to a general audience who know about force and momentum because they've already seen Newton in other situations, why even bring up "pressure"? I suspect this came about when some dumbass said "well everyone knows about pressure because car tires".
Re:How Airplanes Fly: A Physical Description of Lift (1999)
by stoolpigeon on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:22AM
(#10709544)
After bootcamp I went through a US Navy course that covered some basics of aviation related stuff. We were given the Bernoulli explanation - so somehow it made it into official Navy training materials. And I repeated that explanation, because I believed it to be true, until I read this article a few years ago. I have no idea if the training is still the same, it wouldn't surprise me one bit if it is. So that source alone would be producing thousands of people a year who are misinformed.
Re:How Airplanes Fly: A Physical Description of Lift (1999)
by ivyirwin on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:14AM
(#10709017)
Thank you for mentioning this. I don't know how many times I've argues against the classical definition of lift in the last couple of years and finally reverted to the hand out the window explanation. That's usually when it dons on people that lift isn't what they were taught it was.