News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by fein on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @09:44PM (#10708531)
How exactly? If anything this outlines the failure of NICS; not gun manufacturers and FFL's.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by mrsteveman1 on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:35PM (#10708705)
The "business model" argument Comey was making at least becomes somewhat relevant to a national debate on terrorist attacks if you're talking about the actual weapons used in the attacks and the companies that make them.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by 67726e on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:15PM (#10708638)
How is it a failure of NICS?
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by fein on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:27PM (#10708678)
We have plenty of gun laws and methods of checking criminal history already; additional restrictions and laws don't change the fact that criminals are willing to be criminals.

Unless you just want to take guns away from all civilians forever, and in that case I don't think we can have an actual rational dialogue.

edit: I don't mean "you" specifically, I mean the general "you". I can see how that could read wrong.

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by robbiemitchell on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:15PM (#10708845)
Not sure what "we" and "plenty of" mean. This is regulated state by state. And the number of laws (?) is irrelevant if they are ineffective.

Ohio, for instance, has gun shows that advertise on TV and facilitate casual gun sales. Not even a Walmart, just a booth at a convention center.

* Some states have permissive gun regulation.

* There is no consistent, nationwide background check system.

* There is a large field of options between where we are and "take guns away from all civilians forever". We already prevent the sale of grenades. We prevent the sale of gas. Doing so makes it harder for criminals to be criminals in particular ways. We can similarly restrict the sale of certain kinds of weapons to make it harder for criminals to be criminals, just as some of our other rights are restricted outright or through case law (including free speech, freedom to assemble, and others).

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by fein on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:41PM (#10708929)
I'm a native born and so far lifelong resident of Ohio; and I wouldn't have our gun laws any other way (constitutional carry would be nice)

I think something like 1% of gun crimes are committed from firearms purchased from a gun show.

> We already prevent the sale of grenades. We prevent the sale of gas.

Explosives are pretty easy to make. How many pipe bombs were found with the San Bernadino shooters? And this is California in that example, possibly the most restricted state in the US regarding firearms.

Tannerite is legal for purchase in Ohio and California, for example. All you need is a blasting cap to set it off (or shoot it with a gun, which is one hell of a fun afternoon)

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by satori99 on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:43PM (#10708742)
> Unless you just want to take guns away from all civilians forever, and in that case I don't think we can have an actual rational dialogue.

Can I ask why not? I mean, why is it irrational to suggest that civilians not be allowed to own powerful weapons designed to kill humans?

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by fein on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:08PM (#10708820)
I shoot as a hobby (steel and paper), and have a loaded gun on me at all times at home (on the bedstand when sleeping) for self defense. Removing that not only kills a hobby that I love, but also places me at a mortal disadvantage if the situation arises. I'm actually for non violent felons being allowed to still have a right to self defense. If we had a program that could actually rehabilitate violent felons (the prison system DOES NOT do this), I'd be all for those people to be allowed the right to defend themselves as well.

The people that are interested in causing you harm for their own gain really don't care how they do it; at this point in time the best equalizer for all is a firearm.

The angle on a tyrannical government, and keeping that problem in check, is a whole different discussion and probably isn't suited for this forum.

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by Asbostos on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:07AM (#10709128)
Most victims of guns aren't attackers that were shot in self defense. Are you saying it's better that large number of innocent people get killed than a minority of self-defending people? That doesn't sound like a safe solution overall - it only benefits the people who take more action to defend themselves and hurts everyone else.

Question too - how do you use a gun to defend yourself against somebody else with a gun? Doesn't it come down to who can "draw" quicker - which will surely always be the attacker because he's the only one who knows what's about to happen?

Or are you only talking about defending yourself against people without guns who who might use them impulsively so they don't have the advantage of surprise?

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by gnopgnip on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:14AM (#10709320)
Most people killed by guns are victims of suicide. America has a mental health problem. If you want to prevent deaths from guns fix the mental health problems first. If you want to stop people from dying focus on the number preventable cause of death, heart disease.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by fein on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:11AM (#10709312)
Most victims of guns are in gang related skirmishes in poverty centers.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by aianus on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:01PM (#10708797)
> I mean, why is it irrational to suggest that civilians not be allowed to own powerful weapons designed to kill humans?

Because criminals don't care about laws and then they would become the only ones with guns. A law abiding citizen should be allowed the necessary means to protect himself, his family, and his possessions.

Besides that, they're not necessarily designed to kill humans; plenty of people need guns to defend against animals (like anyone working in bear country, farmers protecting chickens against coyotes, etc.)

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by satori99 on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:21PM (#10708868)
I don't really buy the "criminals have them, so I need one too" argument.

Are you genuinely so in fear for your family's' safety, that you need a firearm and ammunition on hand?

If that is the case, and I were in your position,I would seriously consider moving elsewhere before I armed myself.

I live in a country where they were banned some time ago for all civilians who don't have a very good reason for owning one. ("Because I like them", or "I need to protect my property/family" are not considered good reasons).

Many farmers and rural types were very angry about the ban when it was proposed and implemented. But now, the vast majority of the population considers it to be the crowning achievement of the politician who implemented it.

Guns and gun crime are now so rare in my city that almost every time a gun is used to commit a crime it is front page news.

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by fein on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:35PM (#10708912)
> Guns and gun crime are now so rare in my city that almost every time a gun is used to commit a crime it is front page news.

And yet it still happens. Additionally, you're from AU; You have a very different culture and level of poverty that you really don't see in the US. We (the US) have issues with income disparity unseen in a first world country, and the majority of the gun crimes occur in that area (poor urban areas). Poverty is a huge driver for crime. Fix that problem and gun crimes plummet.

Are you aware that knife crimes are up some 10+% in AU versus gun crimes? It seems that the criminals are still willing to be criminals.

Take a look at Vermont for example. Pretty boring if you want to live in an urban area, but probably the safest state in the US with the most relaxed gun laws. Vermont allows concealed carry without a permit; what we call "constitutional carry".

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by satori99 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:07AM (#10708999)
It's true that our respective societies are very different (despite their similarities). We do not really have a small-town society in Australia. Almost all Australians live in large cities, and metro areas. This urban mindset is definitely reflected in our policies and laws.

It is worth noting however, that Sydney (where I live), is larger than every city in the US, except New York. And yet I am vastly (something like 400x) less likely to be the victim of any gun related crime than a US city dweller.

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by cgriswald on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:37AM (#10709208)
That's the trick, isn't it? By referring to "gun crime" it looks like, magically, crime has disappeared along with the guns. But it isn't relevant whether a victim of a mugging is faced with a gun or a knife, so it's not "gun crime" that's interesting, but "crime".

In countries that have banned guns, including Australia, the restriction on guns has done nothing to reduce crime. In every single country that has banned them (again including Australia) there was an initial uptick of crime. The UK in particular had a massive increase in homocides (the number one reason people give as to why guns should be banned) and also saw home invasions where the victims were physically at home at the time of the invasion increase. Australia was lucky in that after its uptick, crime returned to normal rates. In many other countries, crime has continued to trend upward.

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by satori99 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:53AM (#10709262)
I don't think it is down to luck that Australia has had had zero mass shootings by crazy people since the our government implemented a mandatory buyback, and destroyed hundreds of thousands of weapons almost 20 years ago.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by refurb on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:12AM (#10709506)
Mass shootings in Australia were rare before the gun laws were strengthened.

Also, Australia still has guns including plenty of rifles and even handguns. You banned some types of guns, not all of them.

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by satori99 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:29AM (#10710100)
Australia also had only 18M citizens at the time.

But the zero massacres since 1996 is still significant.

Yes, guns are still available for sports shooters, and hunting etc. But we also strengthened the laws concerning how weapons must be stored (in a safe). The police have the right to turn up at the door of any registered gun owner and demand to inspect their storage at any time.

I am not sure how often that actually happens, because my guns are all digital :P

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by cgriswald on Thursday December 10, 2015 @10:47AM (#10711175)
> But the zero massacres since 1996 is still significant.

There have been many massacres since 1996. One even involved guns. All that has happened with the banning of guns is that the weapon of choice for difference crimes has changed. In the case of mass killings, arson seems to have become the weapon of choice.

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by aianus on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:07AM (#10708998)
> If that is the case, and I were in your position, I would seriously consider moving elsewhere before I armed myself.

Most people who live in those areas can't really afford to do that.

In any case, the onus is on the prohibitionist to defend the policy of prohibition, not the other way around. "Guns increased your chances of dying this year by 0.003%" (~11k gun homicides over 300M population) is a totally unmoving argument to me and I suspect most people in the US. At those risk levels, might as well ban cigarettes, motorcycles, aspirin, alcohol, leaving the house...

Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by oldmanjay on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @11:22PM (#10708870)
Bear in mind that technology will soon let people create arms in the privacy of their own home. Then it has to be the idea that gets banned, so good luck.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by Gracana on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:05AM (#10708994)
The technology to make firearms at home has existed for a hundred years.
Re:No Matter What the FBI Says, Compromising Encryption Is a... by oldmanjay on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:44AM (#10709414)
"without special skill," I should have not left unsaid.