Re:Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
by michael_fine on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @05:30PM
(#10707248)
Well, pure self-interest would probably fall outside of morality, but one could make an argument that many conscriped ISIS fighters, US soldiers, and perhaps US leaders are acting out of self-interest.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
by danharaj on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @07:08PM
(#10707873)
Self-interest is not a well defined concept. The notion of self is not somehow objective or immutable. Describing someone's self-interest is just another framework for describing the same underlying system that morality and all that is trying to describe. There is a bit of circularity when one tries to make self-interest an essential feature of brains:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_egoism#Circulari...
In cases like extreme nationalism, the zealot has essentialized the nation-state into their identity and is thus acting in their 'self-interest'. If one defines self-interest as interest in the health and reproduction of the body, then humans are emphatically not drive solely by self-interest.
Re:Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
by tremon on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:43AM
(#10710143)
Why was this down-voted? The parent makes an excellent point that self-interest relies on a moral judgement about who the "self" is.
Re:Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
by Natsu on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @06:23PM
(#10707607)
I think things could get a bit ambiguous when you consider something like the Stalinist purges. Those would seem to be an intersection of self-interest and self-righteousness. Although their morality was not theistic, they clearly believed that they must prevail over those who had wronged them.