News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China slams U.S. "information hegemony" by joe_the_user on Friday January 22, 2010 @02:08PM (#1070400)
Let's look at some statements in your post: Does anyone seriously think that a determined information-seeker in China can't find out whatever information he/she wants?

Google's move to pull out of China, aside from harming average Chinese people.

So "determined information seekers" could the information the information that Google wasn't giving but by no longer providing government approved data, Google is harming average Chinese? I know you're teasing out two different groups in China but the argument seems remarkably stretched.

China has long been a huge buyer of US treasury bills, in order to keep its currency low relative to the dollar. This helps make China's export industry more competitive but harms the Chinese in general.

Given that this policy has allowed China to gain the second largest economy in the world over twenty-odd years, how has it harm average Chinese?

I would certainly say this policy is unsustainable and needs to be adjusted for that reason. But that's a somewhat different matter.

Re:China slams U.S. "information hegemony" by grandalf on Friday January 22, 2010 @02:51PM (#1070509)
On the first point: For the average Chinese person, simply having an awareness of government censorship is a good thing. Google is taking this away. The censorship isn't perfect... for example how many times do you think the full WikiPedia is brought into China on laptops every day? I'd guess dozens per day. Google is suffering the "Napster Problem", they are easily vulnerable to a centralized attack (in this case blocking IPs)... but before and after Napster people still got all the illicit mp3s they wanted.

On the second point, the economic argument would be: If China were not subsidizing its export industry, the dollars currently used to buy US Treasuries would have likely been spent on useful goods and services. Instead, it effectively sat idle and could not be used to invest in infrastructure, etc. You can point to the result and say it worked, but China has a natural competitive advantage in manufacturing, so it's hard to say how much benefit the policy caused; the harm is easier to imagine.

(China probably has some sensible reasons for promoting mercantilist policies, but it's inevitable that they lower prosperity over all and amount to a transfer from one group within china to another. This is the same sort of tradeoff we experience it the US with a wide variety of policies, notably agriculture policy).

Re:China slams U.S. "information hegemony" by joe_the_user on Friday January 22, 2010 @04:59PM (#1070800)
Can you explain why a censored Google makes the Chinese more aware of censoring?
Re:China slams U.S. "information hegemony" by grandalf on Friday January 22, 2010 @05:13PM (#1070837)
All one has to do is compare the search results of google.com to google.cn and the ones not in google.cn are the specific things the Chinese government is trying to stop.

I started a project a while ago called censoredinchina.org which uses this feature to help generate awareness.

I haven't published any code yet, but the goal of the site is to generate images of the censored web pages that can be easily embedded in blogs, etc., where they are more difficult for China's human censors to find/stop.