Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in...
by logn on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @10:06PM
(#10701664)
I think if ingredients were disclosed that, first, harmful ingredients would be reduced or eliminated by the makers, and next the public could debate the issue of banning indoor e-cigs from a position of knowledge.
If every product had to disclose this, then ideally you could recursively query for every component chemical. At that point, not only would banning e-cigs be discussed but also probably many building materials and cleaning products. And we'd be able to ban on a granular level, e.g., any product emitting more than 10 ppm diacetyl.
Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in...
by simoncion on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @03:15AM
(#10702531)
> ...and next the public could debate the issue of banning indoor e-cigs from a position of knowledge.
I very much want to live in a world where the public debates issues from a position of knowledge, rather than positions of deliberate ignorance motivated by tribalistic passions. :(
However, labeling doesn't really help people exposed to second-hand whatnot. The smoker/vaper(/perfume-wearer) may find the ingredients to be acceptable, but what about all the people around them? And unfortunately, smokers are not the most considerate bunch.