Re:Who Y Combinator Companies Want
by Matt_Mickiewicz on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @03:29PM
(#10699236)
Not true.
Actually work sample tests have a .29 correlation to on the job performance, followed closely by structured interview questions.
The work I'm referencing specifically called out Google as an example of an overly-complex practice that didn't result in objectively higher quality candidates. Google's overall quality of engineering talent is high because they are quick to push people out the door if they don't meet the high standards. Regardless, it's very difficult to scale Google's hiring practices, and it's overall seen as a growth limiter for them (even by people internally - it can take 3-6 months to hire one candidate).
According to the psychometrics books I have read structured interviews are as good as IQ-tests when it comes to predicting job-performance.
All types of hiring tests/interviews had some predictive power (except handwriting analysis).
So regardless of what the companies want, it's near impossible to accurately judge someone in an interview process. Even if you know what you want, it's very difficult to assess how someone is going to perform in a job through an interview process. The main benefit of interviews IMO is to help managers "buy-in" on hiring decisions.