News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by dnautics on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @12:51PM (#10698020)
The problem with DNA 'source code' is not that it's hard to read, it's that we don't fully know how to read it. Yes, we know what protein sequence comes out but the chemical consequences are not particularly well known. With google's source code, you could, in theory, look at it long enough and have a working understanding down to the level of electrons moving around specific spots in the chips in the Google datacenter.

As a professional (wet) biochemist and also a coder, my personal feeling is that biology is much, much shallower. However, the knowledge required is broader but incomplete. If you're trying to, say optimize an enzyme, beyond molecular biology, you'd do well to incorporate knowledge from biochemistry (is this an active site amino acid? Maybe I shouldn't touch it. What sort of yield changes can I expect if this enzyme catalyzes the rate-determining step vs. not), cell biology (will adding this amino acid sequence send it to the wrong compartment?), biophysics (will changing this residue mess up the protein fold?), electrochemistry (is the electrical potential of this iron-sulfur cluster consistent with the process I want?) etc etc.

A lot of 'biohackers' are script kiddies that just ctrl-c/ctrl-v gene sequences and hope that it works. That's why you see a lot of gene synthesis companies claim a offer of "codon optimizing" a gene. It's something that sounds hard, sounds critical, and gets something done. The rest of it is much, much harder, and requires actual thought.

Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by vectorjohn on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @03:20PM (#10699163)
Nobody said it was hard to read. The comic you're replying to certainly didn't say that.

I disagree that you could look at Google's source code and know much about the data center. You would have to have a lot more knowledge about infrastructure which is completely hidden from you. And that's about where we are with proteins. We can figure out the protein, and then try to simulate what it would do, but it's not easy or straight forward.

So your analogy with Google source code would be like, you could simulate what a data center might be like, but you're just guessing and could be way off.

I think the point of the comic is that if you look at Google source code, it's NOT straight forward to understand. You can read it, sure. Anyone can read an operating system worth of assembly, too. But knowing what it does, that's a hard problem (without running it). And that Google's code is only a few years of optimization by people trying to keep the code comprehensible instead of billions of years of optimization with no care for readability or organization.

Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by pazimzadeh on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @01:38PM (#10698361)
I'm not sure I understand what you mean when you say that "biology is much, much shallower". Shallower than what, and in what way? What might it look like if it were deeper?
Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by silentplummet on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @02:58PM (#10698992)
When we use a computer programming language, we are directing an abstract machine to interpret and manipulate data to get a result that we want. We have all the knowledge we need about the machine because we conceived and designed it ourselves.

DNA is like a programming language for a biological computer, a living cell. However, we don't know nearly everything there is to know about a living cell. We can't predict its mechanisms. There is no debugger. The compiler didn't come with an instruction manual. The code bootstraps itself into its own machine and runs in an environment we can't predict. And the syntax has been obfuscated and optimized by a genetic algorithm that's been running in parallel on quintillions of cores for a billion years.

Because the code executes on an unknown machine in an unpredictable physical environment, many features we might expect to see in a programming language are missing. This might be what he meant by "shallow".

Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @09:52PM (#10701615)
>DNA is like a programming language for a biological computer, a living cell. However, we don't know nearly everything there is to know about a living cell. We can't predict its mechanisms. There is no debugger. The compiler didn't come with an instruction manual. The code bootstraps itself into its own machine and runs in an environment we can't predict. And the syntax has been obfuscated and optimized by a genetic algorithm that's been running in parallel on quintillions of cores for a billion years.

And, just to finish off, the machine is stochastically nondeterministic.

Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by dnautics on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @08:24PM (#10708230)
I mostly meant that there is tons of encapsulation in computer programming. Like one could be a full-stack engineer that could go from soldering a transistor (or designing an IC from scratch, to writing a web app that uses web sockets that sit on top of HTTP which is on top of TCP/IP sockets, which is served ruby sitting on top of linux which is virtualized by Amazon AWS which is managed by a hypervisor sitting on top of a cluster of computers, all talking to each other via TCP/IP..... etc.), and there are so many layers 'deep' to that cake.

And this is a personal feeling, but there is less encapsulation, in biology. There are less 'categories' of things that build on top of each other that you have to learn, but those categories are immense and the knowledge in each of those is incomplete. I suppose you could say the knowledge in some of programming is 'incomplete' by virtue of closed-source encapsulation (trust us, this hardware works like you think it does), but that is somewhat artificial.

Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by pazimzadeh on Monday December 14, 2015 @03:41AM (#10729988)
Thanks for that explanation. Do you really think the stack is smaller in biology? Biology has been optimized over three billion years - if we've already invented more layers than there are in biology then are we not overthinking it?

This is what I came up with in a hurry for biology:

  ...elements
  atoms
  chemicals
  nucleic acids
  genetic circuitry
  peptides
  proteins
  multiprotein complexes
  microcompartments
  organelles
  cells
  clusters of differentiation
  organs
  organisms
  communities...
Care to fill in or improve the list?
Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by pazimzadeh on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @04:36AM (#10702743)
> Because the code executes on an unknown machine in an unpredictable physical environment, many features we might expect to see in a programming language are missing. This might be what he meant by "shallow".

Without knowing how much more there is to know about biology, how can we expect to see certain features or not? What about tasks that are supremely efficient in biology but resource intensive "in silico"? I'm having a hard time fathoming biology as shallow in any way. The fact that it's bootstrapped and live, that you don't get to restart the computer or cut the flow of information makes it all the less shallow to me, unless I'm misunderstanding how that word was used.

Re:The genetic code now has a workable text editor by bduerst on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @02:08PM (#10698578)
Genome is easy to read, proteonome is hard to understand.

We have a good grasp on protein folding, but we're not to the point where we can fully synthesize proteins from raw genetic sequences. It would be great if we could get there in our lifetime.