News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by bct on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @01:37PM (#106962)
Complaining about Unicode support doesn't mean people haven't been reading pg correctly, it means they disagree about the importance of it.

I don't see how lacking it makes the language any more artistic.

Edit: and characterizing people as pedants for wanting a useful feature is silly and unproductive.

Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by falsestprophet on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @04:36PM (#107090)
I don't think Paul Graham ever said that unicode was not important. I bet he thinks it great. But, right now I think he thinks there are more productive (and more fun) ways to spend his development time. I bet he is right.
Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by rglullis on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @02:18PM (#106991)
The annoying part is about the "complaining", as PG's followers are entitled to anything, just because they feel they are part of the cult.

Guess what? You don't get the right to complain. Nobody does. Nobody has paid a support contract for anyone to include Unicode support on the language.

The guy wrote a language for himself. Not for you, not for me. And he does not want to work on Unicode support. I bet he doesn't want to work on database abstraction. Or Ajax widgets. Or whatever.

If those are so important to you, go somewhere else. But please, stop complaining.

EDIT: bad wording. As bct put it, complain all you want, but don't feel in the right to demand anything.

Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by bct on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @02:24PM (#107001)
> You don't get the right to complain.

Yes we do. What we don't get is the right to demand.

Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by asdflkj on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @05:09PM (#107109)
Yes we do. What we don't get is the right to have our demands met.
Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by vegashacker on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @02:35PM (#107007)
At least in the US, that pesky first amendment does give them the right to complain. :) I certainly agree that pure complaining is annoying, but bring on the well-articulated critiques!

Also, I don't think that PG wrote Arc just for himself. I think he wrote the language that he himself wanted, but that's not the same thing. If Arc was only for him, then why release it to the world? I think what he wants is the best of both worlds -- lots of users, with no support burden. Eventually, the users won't stand for this, but while Arc is still an infant, it makes a lot of sense.

Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by apathy on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @02:41PM (#107011)
> If Arc was only for him, then why release it to the world?

To get people to stop pestering him?

Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by marvin on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @03:27PM (#107034)
Given all the discussion on Hacker News and elsewhere, that is obviously not the reason.
Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by comatose_kid on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @02:24PM (#107000)
I think the argument can be summed up as follows: pg - Arc is an exploratory language, meant to appeal to hackers so they can create great things with it. various sw devs - But we need Unicode support and W3C compliance

How do these requests support the goals of Arc? I think it's funny that people have started complaining about these things (which aren't core to a language) instead of thinking about what kind of cool stuff they can build.

Why does a language that furthers the notion of software as art have to conform to existing conventions?

Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by mdemare on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @04:21PM (#107081)
The cool stuff I want to build happens to involve languages with diacritics. And strings are (or should be) core to programming languages.
Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by derefr on Thursday January 31, 2008 @03:55AM (#107328)
Just an observation: No one complains that Brainfuck lacks strings, and they have fun playing with that. Software doesn't have to be about building things that are useful in the everyday. I can think of plenty of programs to write that don't involve strings.

In fact, I can see one great use for Arc already: a more "hip and modern" language than Scheme that you can convince students to demand they be taught (instead of Blub.) I could envision a version of the SICP written for it by, say, _why.

Re:Dear Programmers, Please Learn to Read Before You Speak: ... by rml on Wednesday January 30, 2008 @02:12PM (#106985)
I don't argue that lacking Unicode support makes the language more artistic. In fact, I don't even argue that Arc is artistic -- only that its author(s) didn't intend to adhere to any particular standards or tastes of our own age (which is what technicians might do), aiming instead to create a useful tool for "sketching out" computations (which is what artists might do). That all seems very clear from the statement on the Arc site.