Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England
by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @06:28PM
(#10693599)
It's fine to talk about non-Bitcoin blockchains, e.g. Litecoin and Dogecoin both have perfectly functional non-Bitcoin blockchains. No one would argue that. The issue is when you try to apply the word "blockchain" to a technology that has been neutered to the point that it no longer has proofs-of-work in it. It's not really a blockchain at that point because you've removed the main innovation that actually makes the blockchain idea useful. That is what the commenter you responded to meant when he said:
> I'm arguing that the bitcoin protocol without the Nakamoto consensus is not an improvement over conventional clearing technology
As an analogy, let's say you design a car with no engine, but still insist on calling it a car because it looks like a car and it has most of the same parts. It's not really an illuminating discussion to keep debating whether or not it should be called a car so long as you understand the objection that the car-shaped-object is no longer useful for the purposes that people commonly associate cars with serving.
> I'm arguing that the bitcoin protocol without the Nakamoto consensus is not an improvement over conventional clearing technology
As an analogy, let's say you design a car with no engine, but still insist on calling it a car because it looks like a car and it has most of the same parts. It's not really an illuminating discussion to keep debating whether or not it should be called a car so long as you understand the objection that the car-shaped-object is no longer useful for the purposes that people commonly associate cars with serving.