News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:E-Prime: English without the verb 'to be' by euyyn on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:26PM (#10691412)
I have trouble imagining how to answer "What's E-Prime; I've never heard of it." without using the semantics of "to be". And answering that seems to me the primary goal of an encyclopedic article.

If the article starts with "E-Prime prescribes..." I still don't know what E-Prime _is_. Is it a committee? Is it a style guide? (Right now the article says it's a version of English, which, if superficially, at least answers the question).

Re:E-Prime: English without the verb 'to be' by obsurveyor on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:13PM (#10692322)
Your original question is invalid because the questioner would never ask it if they only used E-Prime. Let's re-phrase your question with E-Prime: "Describe E-Prime to me, I've never heard of it."

You get the idea now? The very form of the question affects your understanding of the answer. Through the description you receive, you begin to understand what E-Prime means to those that came up with it. In E-Prime, you literally can't state what it is to anyone else because that would go against E-Prime's rules.

Re:E-Prime: English without the verb 'to be' by euyyn on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @01:28AM (#10702241)
The questioner cannot use E-Prime because he doesn't know what E-Prime is. And before being interested in its description, he'll probably want to know what it is (is it a law? is it a game? is it a style guide? a brain training exercise? is it a dog?).

See, "E-Prime" is a proper noun, and proper nouns don't have a meaning; they instead refer to specific things (giving them an identity). The same way Spain is a country, E-Prime is "a variant of English."

Re:E-Prime: English without the verb 'to be' by krupan on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:55PM (#10692184)
You can't ask "What is E-Prime?" if you are not allowed to use the word is.
Re:E-Prime: English without the verb 'to be' by raygunomical on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:43PM (#10694853)
The person who has never heard of E-Prime will use the word "is" when asking what E-Prime means.