News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:07PM (#10691266)
Aren't the miner incentives are only necessary if it's an open blockchain that requires public hashing power?

You can have a relatively smaller number of actors incentivized by other means on a network - e.g. organizations in an industry that validate transactions amongst each other.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by adrianmacneil on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:10PM (#10691284)
True, but decentralized databases (where all nodes are trusted) were already invented long before bitcoin came along. You do not need a blockchain if all actors are trusted.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:22PM (#10691378)
For perfect trust, sure, but amongst competitors in a same market space you would think that it's more 'imperfect' trust, even with contracts.

If the transactions are small and numerous, it would seem easier to maintain a block chain ledger than managing multiple write points and masters for a decentralized database. I'm not saying it's concrete, but it would be an interesting experiment at least.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:44PM (#10691585)
How do you determine who gets to participate in this separate blockchain? Can anyone join? Or are there barriers to entry? Because if there are barriers to entry, then you've now created a single centralized authority that issues these keys, and you thus don't really have a decentralized system at all.

If each participant individually judges the merits of other participants, then everything will quickly diverge as some blocks are accepted by some participants but not by others, and the whole network collapses into forks.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @04:09PM (#10692718)
There are barriers to entry, for the miners - that's the whole point of having a closed block chain. Nodes and addresses could be open depending on the hypothetical.

Mass decentralization is only a selling point for Bitcoin, but even then the Bitcoin organization (who controls the code) has authority to push a hard fork on the miners. They won't do it obviously (e.g. increase block size), because it would alienate their user base.

Miner validation can be controlled by the same organization in charge of the code, which isn't aligned with any one competitor in the industry.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @06:37PM (#10693640)
The only barrier to entry for a Bitcoin miner is that you have to have an Internet connection and a computer. That is completely decentralized; anyone can buy a computer and Internet access. I don't understand your point. Surely any system you were proposing would require that as well. Your comment was talking about a blockchain amongst "organizations in an industry that validate transactions amongst each other". That seems like it would require a barrier to entry to me, namely, that you would have to validate to someone that you were actually so-and-so organization in so-and-so industry. Can you more fully flesh out your proposal? I'm seeing additional barriers to entry, requiring centralization, that Bitcoin does not have.

In practice you probably want a special purpose computer that is GOOD at calculating SHA256 hashes. But anyone can acquire these without limitation or restriction.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @09:16PM (#10694354)
Hard forks push changes to the protocol from a centralized location, namely the bitcoin organization. You know how hard forks work, right?

It's not a "vs. bitcoin" comparison... just an example of how organizations in an industry would use block chain to store numerous small transactions, instead of a decentralized database.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @01:30PM (#10698301)
You keep deflecting and not answering my questions and it's getting really annoying. I'm not going to keep responding to all of your tangents when you can't even address a single one of my points. Please respond to what I've been saying in a relevant manner, then I'll respond to your other stuff.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @02:32PM (#10698762)
I've been telling you that you're making the wrong assumptions about blockchain applications because you're assuming it has to be based on bitcoin designs. Again, a closed blockchain doesn't require it to be open to the public for miners.

If you're getting frustrated and think that is deflecting then it's possible you have a cognitive bias.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by to3m on Monday December 07, 2015 @04:35PM (#10692893)
You don't have to have forks. When there is no agreement, the network can just stop working. Some might think that a bit useless, but when you're trying to reach agreement it is in many respects a lot better than a fork...
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @06:30PM (#10693611)
But then anyone can trivially shut down the network by submitting a single invalid block. The very first bit of abuse and everything is shut down and stops working indefinitely. How could this design serve a useful purpose? It seems a lot less useful than the way Bitcoin does it.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by to3m on Monday December 07, 2015 @06:37PM (#10693642)
But who's going to abuse it? Why would it shut down indefinitely? This is a group of people or entities that has decided to do this. Presumably they all feel it's in their interests to make it work. Same as with any mutual agreement of this kind, if there's some kind of a falling-out, they'll probably just figure it out somehow.

(As for invalid blocks - in the absence of a bug in the code that runs the system, all validators will say no to the invalid block(s), so there's no disagreement, and things carry on.)

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @01:29PM (#10698298)
So now we're back to having trusted parties only, and you thus have centralization, and don't need a blockchain at all. You just need signed transactions among trusted peers. We keep going round in circles.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by to3m on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @07:00PM (#10700800)
It's only centralized from the point of view of somebody who isn't involved. Those who are involved most likely won't see it as such - since if they did, they'd have chosen some other mechanism. They don't need to trust one another.