I don't know how you can say this with any degree of certainty (read: I want your crystal ball). Network effects are incredibly important here, as the security of the system is exactly its total hashing size. Bitcoin has such a head start that I don't see how anything could overtake it without providing incredible new features that can't be implemented even as side-chains.
I can make a token and call it 'potPlantCoin'. That token can be valued at '1 potted plant' of a certain size in my neighborhood blockchain, whereas, the token is backed by a potted plant... I could then effectively have a distributed, decentralized ledger in my neighborhood that uses the value of a potted plant as the means of exchange. I don't have to worry about any other network than the small amount of processing power within the nodes in my neighborhood.
Maybe that example helps you understand how the blockchain doesn't need a 'leader' or something like bitcoin that is 'so far ahead'. Bitcoin is completely irrelevant in my neighborhood. Sorry, no crystal ball here, but I do have an extremely high degree of certainty =p
That's why you use the biggest existing blockchain, not a separate one. There's no way in hell I can cheat you if we do our transactions on the Bitcoin blockchain, because I can't beat the overall hashing power of the system, but I sure as hell can beat your hashing power if we have a blockchain that's only for two people, or just for a neighborhood.
(This is probably what you want, anyway, when the value of the assets that back the network exceeds the value of mounting an attack! You might argue againt the wisdom of having the network secured by general mutual mistrust, but it's no worse than relying on cost.)
Thus far it is shaping up to be a powerful platform with some realistic potential to changes to how internet software is built.
> Ethereum's chain is a mess.
I'm unsure what you mean here.
> It's only burning 25k USD per day, and the project plans to switch off of it entirely.
Burning 25k USD of what? Switch off of what?
> The claim that this project can cure whatever ails you on such a weak foundation is at best dubious, and probably just a scam.
Which claims are you referring to. What part of Ethereum is a scam?
Vitalik knows the Ethereum chain won't scale so he's renovating the entire thing to Proof of Stake. (Which is a bad idea as well). Hunt around this is public knowledge.
Claims: There are so many. If you haven't seen them , watch the videos of the Ether team during the crowdsale.
If you haven't heard of Ethereum, check it out. It seems to be one of the leaders in blockchain platforms. Even Microsoft is working with it, along with many others.
Bitcoin, although the largest chain right now, will be a small player in an enormous field. The idea of one cryptocurrency to lead them all is not going to work. In fact, the 'currency' part is somewhat insignificant relative to what the blockchain industry will be. Every 'token' or 'currency' that represents an asset in a smart contract, or an asset such as cash, will be easily and instantly exchangeable for any other liquid asset. (i.e. U.S. Dollars). Having something like bitcoin is actually little use to us. That's not saying I think bitcoin was stupid or bad, it has done much to further the blockchain advancement.