News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:71 percent of top colleges still have policies that sever... by joe_the_user on Thursday January 21, 2010 @10:42PM (#1069056)
Hmm,

Universities have traditionally had codes of conduct. They weren't invented by pot-smoking hippies.

Tenure is based on the idea that after working like a dog and reaching to top of your field, you should then get an unrestricted forum to express yourself - you've earned it.

The examples of someone being falsely accused and convicted of racial harassment don't prove that students should be able to shout racist and sexist slogans whenever they want. It shows that universities should correctly aply statutes against harassment in a reasonably limited fashion.

So, of course, universities should restrict some speech. They certainly go overboard in some cases but that's a different matter.

Re:71 percent of top colleges still have policies that sever... by Perceval on Friday January 22, 2010 @01:16AM (#1069222)
Well, no one should shout racist and sexist slogans whenever they want--inside academia or out. Nevertheless, people--inside academia and outside--should have the right to say controversial and offensive things, express themselves, and read the books they choose to. I am not clear why people outside of academia should enjoy broader freedom to speak their minds and read controversial books than people inside academia.

I entirely agree with you that behavior intended to disrupt or harass should not be tolerated, but the speech codes are clearly written with the intent to prevent certain types of speech, opinions, or political positions.