News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Science-fictional shibboleths by lmm on Monday December 07, 2015 @07:35AM (#10689015)
Eh. It seems weird that you'd object to these things and read fantasy instead, where the list of things that wouldn't work that way is much longer. Unless you know a lot about space physics and hardly anything about medieval history?
Re:Science-fictional shibboleths by jeremysmyth on Monday December 07, 2015 @08:17AM (#10689198)
In writing fantasy, you don't even try to base mechanics on current theory. Fantasy is predominantly about relationships, where the mechanisms of action are useful for furthering character colour and the plot but not in themselves key plot points.

In sci-fi, the mechanisms tend to be at least plausible developments of current theory. In some cases, they even form the basis of the work rather than a mere plot point. Compare Greg Egan's oeuvre, where in many cases the mechanism is the point of the work rather than a plot device.

Re:Science-fictional shibboleths by mcguire on Monday December 07, 2015 @10:13AM (#10689922)
On the other hand, all of the medieval castles I've seen have holes in the walls (somewhere high, in the name of security) where one would dump one's faeces out. Failure to take that in account is an error muchly similar to what is described here for sci-fi.