News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Japanese leaders attacked Pearl Harbor by SolarNet on Saturday December 05, 2015 @04:46PM (#10683383)
Yes, but you can use history to make an educated guess about what will happen.
Re:Why Japanese leaders attacked Pearl Harbor by pixl97 on Saturday December 05, 2015 @05:17PM (#10683472)
History does not tell you about new things. For example, how will technology affect the outcome of war. Evolution is another such thing. You're poisonous caterpillar that no one can eat, you prosper, then suddenly you get decimated by a bird that can stomach your poison.
Re:Why Japanese leaders attacked Pearl Harbor by jacquesm on Saturday December 05, 2015 @05:24PM (#10683493)
> For example, how will technology affect the outcome of war.

That's one thing you do learn from history. You'll win this one if you have the technology and your opponent does not. Otherwise you lose. The next war, you'll both have the technology.

Re:Why Japanese leaders attacked Pearl Harbor by vlehto on Saturday December 05, 2015 @09:17PM (#10684101)
Catch here is to know what is relevant technology.

In 1935 USSR was pioneer in monoplane fighters with retractable undercarriage. They we're two or three years ahead of anybody else, and the Russians had them in relatively large quantity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polikarpov_I-16

Problem was that they didn't know it was relevant. When war started they still mostly relied on biplanes. And only got the development rolling again in 1940 with MIGs and they could not compete with Nazis in the sky on even terms until 1943.

Japanese had total miss with Yamamoto class ships. Germany didn't invest enough in submarines and their tanks we're way too fancy for field repairs. Nobody understood how important submachine guns would be. Brits had some major naval defects, exposed by explosion of HMS Hood and problems with guns of King George V battleships. France and U.S. fucked up tank development. U.S. made thuderbolts, which we're about twice as costly and difficult to built than what was necessary.

It's complete hit and miss. Currently U.S. has global military hegemony because they can afford to miss more than anybody else. Also logistics. If you are committed to get more stuff to the front than the enemy, you can compensate quite lot.

Re:Why Japanese leaders attacked Pearl Harbor by hasenj on Sunday December 06, 2015 @12:45AM (#10684509)
I read somewhere on wikipedia that Japan did some research on nuclear weaponry but concluded it's not feasible.
Re:Why Japanese leaders attacked Pearl Harbor by hga on Sunday December 06, 2015 @12:01PM (#10685718)
Not feasible for them, they didn't have a supply of uranium ore, nor the industrial capability to make use of it. I think if the Germans had done everything right and started in earnest soon enough (they didn't, period), they could have rode the plutonium path to a working bomb in time.

But sometimes the smallest of things derails you. The scientists' saving throw for a real program failed when the bigwigs Nazis were invited to a seminar, but the secretary sending out the invitations accidentally included in the packets the agenda for a different and very technical seminar they'd have no interest in.