Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run
by zo1 on Friday December 04, 2015 @12:18PM
(#10677571)
Have you considered approaching your dilemma from a moral perspective rather than a utilitarian/efficiency one? It may very well be that the two sides have different efficiency profiles, but one outweighs the other in terms of being more moral.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run
by existencebox on Friday December 04, 2015 @04:36PM
(#10679330)
At the risk of driving this question into the bowels of philosophy, I'm VERY hesitant to drive anything from a moral argument, because I don't trust most judgements of morality, my own included. I can establish the empirical success of certain things by many metrics, a moral metric is not one of them. (I have and do regularly approach the question of "what is the utility / what should be my preference in terms of a moral metric", but again this seems to be like the prior "great question of X" but where X is religion/philosophy instead of govt.)
There are certainly times when a moral argument is attractive (and which I would pragmatically chose, especially in the many cases when there are material impacts against which a certain moral stance would oppose) but if we're having a conceptual discussion, I generally avoid that, and even in the cases when I would support a moral argument, I often seek other justifications of more utilitarian nature to try and support the moral suggestion.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run
by dragonwriter on Friday December 04, 2015 @04:37PM
(#10679334)
> Have you considered approaching your dilemma from a moral perspective rather than a utilitarian/efficiency one?
There are an infinite number of possible moral perspectives; utilitarianism is one of them.