News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by CWuestefeld on Thursday January 21, 2010 @12:12PM (#1067715)
Perhaps. But the IPCC is sold (and mostly accepted) as a sort of bible of climate change science. The article you linked appears to me not to claim such broad authority, but to advocate skepticism.

It seems to me like items in the first category need to be held to a higher standard. Indeed, the scientific method itself tells us that those putting forward a theory (such as AGW) bear the burden of proof.

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by ugh on Thursday January 21, 2010 @12:28PM (#1067754)
>Perhaps. But the IPCC is sold (and mostly accepted) as a sort of bible of climate change science.

Oh, come on. Really? Sure, most people won't question the IPCC. But most people also won't question other similar institutions. The real question is whether scientists feel that the IPCC is their bible. And I don't think they do.

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by yters on Thursday January 21, 2010 @02:13PM (#1068058)
I read the FOIA feedback on the IPCC's report and it was full of really incredulous scientists' comments about the innacuracy and question begging nature of their report.

To substantiate what I said, check in the documents folder: ipcc-tar-master.rtf ipcc-tar-master2.rtf

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by lutorm on Thursday January 21, 2010 @12:47PM (#1067805)
Anthropogenic global warming is not a theory being put forth, it's the logical consequence of physical principles that are well established. It's not at all like Einstein proposing General Relativity. What (serious) people are arguing over is details of the analysis and the magnitude of effects. Those uncertainties are real, but it is no different from any other scientific debate.

The article I linked, if you actually read it, does not advocate skepticism at all. It claims in no uncertain language that the greenhouse effect violates all kinds of established principles, but it's hogwash. I saw that article cited in The Nation, and it aggravated me enough that I wrote up a response (http://www.familjenjonsson.org/patrik/research/greenhouse, if you are interested).

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by CWuestefeld on Thursday January 21, 2010 @01:29PM (#1067927)
Anthropogenic global warming is not a theory being put forth, it's the logical consequence of physical principles that are well established. It's not at all like Einstein proposing General Relativity.

I'm sorry to be blunt, but this is just plain wrong, and shows a profound misunderstanding of the scientific method.

First, do you think that Einstein was just making stuff up from whole cloth? No, he was working from well-established physical principles, building onto it using logical reasoning. Despite the fact that his reasoning was logical, there was still every reason for requiring verification (and indeed, Einstein insisted on it) because there could be alternative explanations.

Similarly, AGW builds on known principles like the "greenhouse effect". But the way it seeks to apply these to a hideously complex, chaotic system requires extensive verification. What's known to be true at the micro level might not be applicable to the entire system at all.

Thus, the theory of AGW is precisely like that of General Relativity in that it absolutely requires verification. (Unfortunately, it's unlike GR in that it's not so easily experimented upon)

The scientific method requires that the burden of proof is on the claimant. The one proposing a theory has the responsibility to prove it; the world at large need not disprove it. It must work this way, because it's generally not possible to prove the opposite. When you say you saw Elvis, you can't require that I prove that you didn't.

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof#Burden_of_proof...

[Edit: spelling fix] [Edit #2: I'm really dismayed to see the parent post getting up-voted. I can't fathom how you can assert that AGW is not a "theory being put forth", and thus escapes the requirement of proof.]

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by lutorm on Thursday January 21, 2010 @01:51PM (#1067979)
Sorry, but if you think that AGW and General Relativity are statements of similar stature, you need to learn more physics. General Relativity could not be derived from the prevailing paradigm at the time (Newtonian physics). It was a completely new framework proposed to explain certain observations that could not be explained in Newtonian physics. In contrast, AGW was not proposed to explain any observation. It was derived from accepted physics.

Not that I ever said that you don't need to subject either to tests. You absolutely do. But if you think you can "prove" a scientific theory, I think it is you who is showing a profound misunderstanding of the scientific method.

You can never prove a scientific theory, you can only disprove it. You can confirm a theory a million times but that does not imply that it will work the next time. It does however give us some amount of confidence that it will.

My point is that as far as scientific statements go, that AGW happens is like saying "I think the ball will fall", while to say that it doesn't happen is to say "I think the ball will fall, but imperceptibly slowly.". Both should be tested, but given that one agrees with known physics and one does not, I think the latter should be viewed with more suspicion.

But maybe that's just me.

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by CWuestefeld on Thursday January 21, 2010 @02:19PM (#1068075)
You can never prove a scientific theory, you can only disprove it. You can confirm a theory a million times but that does not imply that it will work the next time. It does however give us some amount of confidence that it will.

Your definition of "prove" is too narrow. From my online WordWeb dictionary:

Verb: prove (proved,proven) 1. Be shown or be found to be 2. Establish the validity of something, as by an example, explanation or experiment 3. Provide evidence for 4. Prove formally; demonstrate by a mathematical, formal proof 5. Put to the test, as for its quality, or give experimental use to ...etc...

Many senses of this word relate to subjecting something to a test, rather than proof in the mathematical sense.

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 21, 2010 @03:48PM (#1068282)
AGW is the claim that human emission of CO2 (rather than other causes) has caused most of the warming trend that the earth has seen since the industrial revolution. Please explain how to derive this conclusion from accepted physics.
Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2010 @04:21PM (#1068360)
That is not an accurate assessment of AGW. The current thinking basically balances an increase in particulate emissions which over the short term reduce global temperature average with greenhouse gasses which increase global temperature (plus a host of other factors). The fact that CO2 is extremely stable means than it accumulates in the atmosphere so its effects accumulate over time. Several other greenhouse gasses are modeled including water and methane, but their long term impact is reduced with time.

Now the long term stability of CO2 vs. methane is based on simple chemistry, and water rains. As to why CO2 would increase the greenhouse effect see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absorption_spectrum and its overall concentration in the atmosphere.

PS: Looking back in history the accumulation effect of CO2 works in reverse so other man made impacts could have easily dominated it.

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 21, 2010 @05:19PM (#1068506)
AGW is the theory of Anthropogenic Global Warming. Anthropogenic means "caused by humans". What you described is basic radiation transfer and mass balance.
Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2010 @09:51PM (#1068982)
Well if you accept the physics of increasing CO2 in the air. Then you need to look at the chemistry of burning the gigantic quantities of mostly solid carbon in Coal C + O2 in the air => an even larger quantity of CO2 by volume in the air. Some basic math on the mass of Carbon released from Coal + Hydrocarbons (which mostly end up as CO2 and H20 after complete combustion) you find that tracks with the increase of CO2 in the air.

Like most complex scientific theories there are several steps of logic involved. And while a few groups agree on which specific steps break the chain a slightly larger but still small group of people can agree that it's broken.

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by InclinedPlane on Thursday January 21, 2010 @06:46PM (#1068719)
The theory of AGW is based on climate modelling. Climate modelling is a brand new science with a very short heritage and very little experimental verification. It is silly to say that climate modelling is derived from "accepted principles", as if it were borne from first principles.

All modern climate "models" are horrible hacks. All contain one or more empirically determined "fudge factors". All gloss over numerous critical important elements of climate dynamics (such as clouds) because they are too difficult to model currently, or we lack understanding of their mechanisms.

The idea that anyone anywhere on Earth has some pristine from-first-principles climate model that you can input data into, turn some crank and spit out data on the climate of the future with any degree of certainty is just plain wrong. Nobody has an accurate model of climate. The AGW proponents have been claiming that they have created accurate climate models (to a degree), but the evidence to back that up is extremely thin. And, what's more, we've discovered recently that the evidence is even thinner than we thought it was.

This is why people object so much to the AGW doomsayers, because the evidence is very much lacking. At best, at best, there's a tiny window of a few decades where some models of climate show a similar trend in global average temperature to the actual trend. And on this tiniest thread of "evidence" so the entire catastrophic AGW theory and all of its proscriptives on human behavior and industry hangs.

Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2010 @12:46PM (#1067803)
In the scientific communality IPCC is mostly viewed as reasonably accurate if watered down for political reasons.
Re:Climate Change Authority Admits Mistake by LargeWu on Thursday January 21, 2010 @02:27PM (#1068097)
Telling that you use the word bible, as the Holy Bible, to which this is a simile, is usually accepted by its believers based on faith, regardless of how outlandish its claims of truth might be.

I'm not saying global climate change isn't real and isn't a threat, but I think there's a lot more religion and faith behind the idea then there ought to be from the scientific community, and especially the media.