Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau...
by jsdalton on Thursday January 21, 2010 @01:31PM
(#1067935)
Sorry, question, why do you say that potatoes have no nutritional value? Everything I have found seems to indicate potatoes are high in nutritional value (e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potato#Nutrition). I have also heard it said that it is possible to subsist entirely on a diet of milk and potatoes, as many Irish families did for quite a long time.
Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau...
by bobdole2695 on Thursday January 21, 2010 @03:12PM
(#1068195)
Survive does not mean thrive.
The Irish have also had a long time to adapt to that diet. They're much less carb sensitive than others. Hence the difference between people from cultures who've eaten a traditionally low-carb diet vs those eating a high-carb diet. Native Americans suffer greatly, but those who traditionally farmed (Asians who eat rice for example) are healthy.
Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau...
by anonjon on Thursday January 21, 2010 @12:34PM
(#1067775)
"(I've resolved that if any of my children ever want to be vegetarians, I'm OK with that, but a critical precondition is that they demonstrate that they have done their homework and understand the nutritional implications. I believe it can be done safely, but it's not trivial; it takes work in our environment.)"
You legitimately have a point that there are certain nutritional deficiencies that vegans/vegetarians are more prone to.
That said, I would hope that whether or not the child is a vegan, you would have him understand the nutritional implications of what he is eating. Being an omnivore safely is also quite difficult.
(Yes, part of the reason some vegetarians are vegetarians is because plants can be more rich in nutrients, but it is not automatically balanced, and some vital nutrients are more challenging to get than others.)
In that case, a vegetarian ends up eating a not-excessively-large portion of carbs naturally.
A bad vegetarian who assumes if it's not meat it must be healthy can still get in trouble, not just on this front but on others as well. It's not that simple.
(I've resolved that if any of my children ever want to be vegetarians, I'm OK with that, but a critical precondition is that they demonstrate that they have done their homework and understand the nutritional implications. I believe it can be done safely, but it's not trivial; it takes work in our environment.)