carry propagation bugs are well-studied
True. But they tend to be well-studied by computer security people, not by mathematicians; and most computer security people won't have the necessary number theory / group theory background.
This is precisely the class of bugs for which proper assessment requires mathematicians who study computer security... aka. NSA employees.
Re:OpenSSL Security Advisory
by Ar-Curunir on Thursday December 03, 2015 @10:41PM
(#10674449)
You'll be surprised by the background of many computer security people. It's a varied field consisting of people with all kinds of backgrounds.
My background is mathematics too. But I'm not a mathematician, and I wouldn't trust myself to know enough mathematics to figure out how something like this could be exploited.
Anecdote: a computer security professor at my university has deep roots in biology. Everything he touches has traces of evolution and homeostasis.
>Ralf-Phillip Weinmann had a good Black Hat presentation about this bug class.
The good news about this particular bug is that carry propagation bugs are well-studied (they seem to be the textbook case of a bignum math bug), and if OpenSSL says they've scoped down the places this bug impacts, they're probably right.
I don't know if it mitigates your existential dread, but carry propagation bugs in multiplication routines are not in fact all that rare.