That's not really an answer to you; rather, it seeks to provide rhetorical relief for the native pondering whether he is morally obligated to throw open his borders. He or she is not. Their survival, and even comfort, are legitimate goods. They may calculate utility differently than their would-be neighbors, and that's OK. Vote, let them vote, converse; but don't attempt to dialectically back them into a corner. Friends don't criticize each others' utility functions.
Certainly, but the feeling I get from the original comment is: "There are no reasons to act selfishly ever." I'm not arguing in favor of 100% selfishness; I'm arguing against a zero-tolerance policy towards it.
Further, the form of the whole thing is troubling. If someone asked you, "How should we help the impoverished citizens of X?" My first response would likely be foreign aid of some sort, or perhaps free trade. But I don't get the feeling that proponents of open borders would be satisfied with those (assuming for the sake of argument that they would indeed help). Beggars can't be choosers; the focus on one method makes it feel more like a shakedown than a plea for help.
[0] http://alphagameplan.blogspot.de/2015/12/culture-and-civiliz...
Why should we deny equal rights (the right to work or move freely) to human beings based on their national origin?
Why should we prevent a woman from off the street from coming in your house and eating your family's food?
Sure we are all born on this and of this planet, but it is human nature to form alliances such that our groups are stronger than any one of us, these alliances and groups exist at multiple scales, from families to nations. Most political nations have a very high overlap with an ethno-nation, which are basically really big families.
It is a proxy. Most likely if you were born in X you were born by parents born in X. Most likely if your parents grew up in X they will raise you to fit into X.
And once again it is between etnical groups. (The previous that I can think of where mostly Northern Ireland and Northern Spain with a few lone wolves in between.)
Not arguing here that immigration shouldn't be simplified but be ware that it isn't just rainbows and unicorns.
> foreign nationals are denied basic rights that US citizens take for granted
I'd say at least modern US is skeptical to everyone, regardless of race, religion, color, ethnicity etc - don't we regularly complain here about how TSA even stops US citizens with US passports at the US Border? : )
In addition to the economic argument, I think there is a compelling moral argument to opening borders. Why should we deny equal rights (the right to work or move freely) to human beings based on their national origin?
If someone today told you the Jim Crow laws were economically justified in modern America - "we can't allow desegregation, blacks will compete with whites for jobs" - you'd see them as a disgusting, backwards racist. And yet in the US, foreign nationals are denied basic rights that US citizens take for granted. Does anyone believe these laws are actually just, or do we just support unjust laws we (mistakenly) think are to our economic advantage?