And before replying to this, read this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1006657
I've been guilty, and occasionally still am guilty, of exactly what PG is observing. You can disagree without attacking each other, and you can make your points without snide asides.
Please.
There is a lot of research out there suggesting that while this program may be a fast way to teach troubled kids to read, there's also a lot of research suggesting that it'll completely destroy their intrinsic motivation to learn and, frankly, to do much of anything in the future. Now maybe there is some special reason why the research doesn't apply in this case, or maybe Gates believes it does apply but the tradeoff is worth it. But most likely I don't think Gates even knows that this research exists, and more generally about this wider branch of theory that suggests that this whole approach is going to be really harmful to these kids.
That's what bothers me, the fact that he's pushing this program really hard without an honest discussion about its merits and drawbacks.
This second-hand anecdote is light on details so I think we cannot draw too deep of conclusions about Gates' character from it.
EDIT: I am not being sarcastic or anything.