News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama Supports $675,000 File Sharing Verdict by kiba on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @07:08PM (#1066195)
What file-sharers or the law say is irrelevant to the fact or non-fact that copying is stealing. Nor whether or not file-sharers want free stuff have anything to do with the non-fact and fact of copying and stealing being an equivalent. Authority and intention doesn't matter. What does matter if it logically make sense to make equivalent the crime of copying to stealing.

To steal is to deprive someone of their property.

To copy is to make duplicates of something. There is no deprivation of property occurring.

Therefore, copying is NOT stealing.

Re:Obama Supports $675,000 File Sharing Verdict by city41 on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @10:13PM (#1066510)
Has this conversation really fallen to the technicalities of a definition in 3 replies? That's not a good sign. Go ahead and define it anyway you want, I really don't care. They are acquiring something of which they did not pay for and do not have a legal right to have, that sure is stealing in my book. Ask the creators if they care what the difference is, I'm pretty sure they don't either.

Beyond that, I can pretty much copy and paste my last response to be used here. What you or anyone "feels" is correct or logical is completely irrelevant. The only thing that is relevant is the law and how we as a society choose to create them and enforce them.

Re:Obama Supports $675,000 File Sharing Verdict by kiba on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:13PM (#1066604)
Beyond that, I can pretty much copy and paste my last response to be used here. What you or anyone "feels" is correct or logical is completely irrelevant. The only thing that is relevant is the law and how we as a society choose to create them and enforce them.

Relevant to who, by what standard, and who this "society" you speak of?

EDIT:

Are we're really even debating the same thing?

EDIT2: I feel that there has been some breakdown in communication.