A year ago I could fly on the same airplane to the same destination and not face a baggage charge. Nowadays I'm faced with a baggage charge, when I got the exact same service for less in the past.
So no, the problem isn't with being charged more for using more services. The problem is being charged more for the same service.
And to expand on your hotel example, many hotels offer a complementary breakfast. If that were to be removed my appreciation of that hotel would fall based on that change.
Perhaps the issue is that Orbitz and others haven't incorporated the number of bags one plans on checking into the "total cost" figure presented in their summaries? If I know what the pricing structure is at the time I make my choice, I'm probably happier.
I went on a trip recently. The combined weight of me and my luggage was perhaps 225 pounds. The combined weight of the young lady standing in line behind me and her luggage was probably 165 pounds. She had to pay substantially more to check two bags instead of one.
As I understand the reasoning, luggage prices increased due to the fuel cost increase of a couple of years ago. Yet somehow me being a foot taller, weighing 70 pounds more, and checking only one bag is cheaper for the airline? I don't understand it.
I think I should have to pay more because of my fat ass.
Let's presume that the airlines will price in a profit optimizing way and that, in the long term, competition will limit their overall take. So, compared to a model where all passengers pay an all-inclusive fee, those using fewer services will pay less under the a-la-carte plan.
We don't think that hotels should be required to include dinner in the cost of the room, but we get mad when the airline charges $5 for an in-flight meal. We're happy to pay per-lb to ship stuff via UPS, but we don't want to pay per-lb for the bags we check? I don't understand.