News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by Overtonwindow on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:59AM (#10655308)
What subject do you teach? I was talking to an old physics professor of mine and he said the same thing, but my former psych professor was completely the opposite. Maybe it's a subject-related issue?
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by JulianMorrison on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:08AM (#10655372)
Could also be related to the person. A prof who's being racist will receive more criticism for being racist, and will have more cause to complain of "political correctness".
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by CodeCube on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:31AM (#10655549)
I gotta say, anecdotally, this is what I often find ... the people complaining about political correctness, are those that have in the past been openly racist, or at a minimum, fond of racially charged jokes (ie. "black people are great, everyone should own one"). They are chafing against a cultural change that no longer appreciates and/or tolerates behavior like that.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:52AM (#10655683)
Yeah. As a white guy, I get that our current loss of privilege feels like a loss. Change is always uncomfortable, so I can see why people would be inclined to push back. And I get that we all learned to express privilege partly through behaviors that conveniently just happen to maintain privilege (behaviors like those racist jokes).

But still, it's frustrating how many people who supposedly pride themselves on their incisive intellects refuse to even consider that there might be something going on besides "political correctness". This Wondermark cartoon captures the dynamic for me:

http://wondermark.com/1k71/

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @10:57AM (#10656271)
People aren't just scared of being forbidden from making racist jokes. People are scared of being forbidden to express opinions.

Like, here's someone who was fired for saying someone else shouldn't have been fired: http://www.gamerevolution.com/manifesto/turtle-rock-communit...

And it makes me pretty uncomfortable when people express "fear of being attacked for doing something that's okay", and other people turn that into "fear of being attacked for doing something that's not okay", and attack them for it.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:30PM (#10657190)
My problem with this line of argument is that people who aren't well-off straight white guys like myself are already scared of expressing opinions. They have been for centuries. The only thing that has changed is that people with privilege, on rare occasion, can no longer say certain things without any consequence.

As Popehat writes, freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences. There's an important question of what consequences should or can legitimately flow from speech. But when this "people shouldn't be scared to express opinions" line gets trotted out only to defend white guys, it's a tell. The nominal principle might be freedom of speech, but if the only people defended are the privileged, the actual principle is maintenance of societal privilege.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @01:04PM (#10657437)
Let's be clear. You're saying it's okay to fire people for saying "it's not okay to fire people for bigotry". Yes? If you're not okay with that, if you think Josh Olin should not have been fired, please say so.

I can see your argument, here. I disagree with you, but that's not what I want to get at here.

What I want to get at is this: it's one thing to be scared of making racist jokes. It's another thing to be scared of expressing opinions like "Donald Sterling should not have been fired".

When people say "I'm scared to express opinions", and then you attack them "ha ha, look at the white people complaining that they're afraid to make racist jokes, how sad for them" - and then you also say that it's okay to fire people for the opinions that they say they're scared to express...

I don't have a polite term for this.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @03:08PM (#10658359)
I am not in fact saying that particular incident is or is not ok. (I also don't think his tweets are fairly characterized by your summation.) As I mentioned, I am addressing the line of argument, not the case.

What I amsaying is that when the "freedom of speech" flag only gets hauled out for pro-bigotry straight white guys, I think it's not really about freedom of speech but instead defense of privilege. If defenders of free speech want to convince me they're serious, they'll be just as vigorous in defending unpopular opinions of people not in their demographic.

That may even be you, in which case, congrats. But unlike you, I don't think it's unconditionally bad that some people are afraid to express opinions because they may face social consequences for them. E.g., if some of the Donald Sterlings of the world are now afraid to express their bigotry, that's ok by me. And if some people are afraid to publish something because they aren't sure whether or not it's bigoted, I also have a hard time seeing that as bad. That seems like a fine opportunity for them to consider their opinions before publishing them.

In fact, I think that's what most people do. The only thing that's different is that straight white guys now have to do the same sort of self-managing that everybody else has always done, because they're now slightly less insulated from the consequences of their actions.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @03:54PM (#10658668)
You're addressing a line of argument about which I said "that's not what I want to get at". And you're ignoring the actual thing that I've been talking about. The thing about which I said "it makes me pretty uncomfortable when..." and "I don't have a polite term for this".

I disagree with some of what you're saying, and I agree with other bits of it. But I strongly disagree with the thing that you're doing and not even acknowledging.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @11:24PM (#10660940)
Just so we're clear, your complaint is that I'm talking about the thing I want to talk about, rather than me talking about the thing you want me to talk about? I'm not immediately seeing my obligation here.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @04:10AM (#10661827)
I have multiple complaints! For one, you're a bully. For two, you're changing the subject when I point out your bullying. And now we can add three, you're changing the subject when I point out your changing the subject.

Are you trying to paint me as some kind of tyrant here? Who said anything about obligation? Feel free to ignore me, feel free to talk about whatever you like. Meanwhile, I will feel free to point out when I don't like the things you say.

Like so: it is a shitty tactic to pretend you're talking to me, to reply as though you have a reply to what I said, and thus to obscure the fact that you're presenting no defense for your actions.

I don't know if this is malice or incompetence on your part, but it's bullshit.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @10:21AM (#10663433)
Dude, you replied to my comment. I am not "changing the subject". I was agreeing with CodeCube and extending his point. To the extent there is a subject here, it is covert and overt racists chafing that they can no longer be quite as racist as they are used to.

It's not my job to address whatever hobbyhorse you've ridden in on, one I still only find half comprehensible. HN discussion is a recreation for me, one I do on my terms. If you would like to make dealing with you my job, feel free to book me at my consulting rate, $300/hr, cash in advance. I have open slots starting in mid-January. Otherwise, please march back on out of my mentions. Thanks.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @12:11PM (#10664206)
HN discussion is a public forum, and you don't get to dictate who replies to you. If you don't want to talk to me, that's up to you. You can simply stop talking to me. I'll get bored and wander off and you won't see me replying to you. If you don't understand what I'm saying, you can also choose to ask clarification. But I'm not asking any positive action of you.

What I do ask is that if you choose to reply to me, you reply to the things that I actually say. Instead, you repeatedly chose to say things which sounded like replies, but weren't. You tried to hide your lack-of-response - first, by talking about something unrelated to what I said, and second, by being all "I don't need to talk about what you want to talk about". Of course you don't! But if you're not going to talk about it, you don't get to pretend you replied to me.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @01:11PM (#10664670)
I replied to the portion of your comment I thought relevant. Stomp your feet all you want, but I don't owe you anything further, and acting entitled to interaction on your terms doesn't incline me to take you seriously.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @01:40PM (#10664873)
Of course you owe me nothing, and of course I'm not entitled to interaction from you, on any terms. I've said twice, and now I say a third time, that you can stop interacting with me any time you like.

But while you choose to interact with me, I am free to point out when you're violating conventions of discourse.

I am not entitled to your words, and you are not entitled to my silence.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Thursday December 03, 2015 @11:54AM (#10670636)
In civilized society, yes, people are entitled to be left alone when they ask to be left alone. I am not entitled to your general silence, but you are not entitled to keep bugging me. Please go away.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Thursday December 03, 2015 @01:00PM (#10671244)
I consider that I'm entitled to keep talking to you, as long as you keep talking to me. It chafes to be told otherwise. On top of that, you're asking me to do something that you could have accomplished yourself, by simply not asking me to do it. That feels like some kind of bizarre power grab.

These things make me want to push back and do the opposite of what you want, just to annoy you.

However, very well: I will not reply to you again in this thread, even if you choose to reply to me.

I don't intend to deliberately avoid replying to you in future.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Saturday December 05, 2015 @02:54PM (#10683057)
The difference being, of course, that you approached me. I believe I have the right to be let alone when asked. You believe that you have the right to approach anybody, petulantly insist that they talk about what you want, and then hang around bothering them after being asked to go away. Assertion of boundaries only seems like a bizarre power grab to the irrationally entitled.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by noobermin on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @01:41PM (#10657703)
I think the proper response is to not silence or discourage any speech, but to make sure non-straight white (non-){0,1}guys have no fear of speaking just like their straight white brethren.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by wpietri on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @02:52PM (#10658229)
I agree almost entirely. I think there's a fair bit of speech that's worth discouraging with other speech. (For example, my part of California is dense with anti-vaxxers. To the extent that they're capable of rational discussion of the topic, I prefer that. But I'd rather have them afraid of pushing their nonsense then let them make other people afraid of vaccinating.) But I definitely think we should be striving for a standard that's equal with respect to things like race and gender.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by Frondo on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:25PM (#10657149)
A smart, capable community manager like Josh Olin should have no problem finding work with another game studio--one that would be OK with his public defense of the bigoted views of that basketball team owner.

Maybe there aren't a lot of employers around who want to hire someone who promotes the view that "bigotry is OK," but surely there's at least one.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:38PM (#10657250)
I've said that someone shouldn't have been fired for what they said, and you've said they can get another job. That is not reassuring.

You've also turned a defense of a person into a defense of their views. You've turned "someone shouldn't be fired for bigotry" into "bigotry is okay". That is not reassuring either.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by Frondo on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:44PM (#10657291)
No one should ever be fired for saying anything?

Or just "bigotry is OK, leave this bigot alone" is something someone should not be fired for?

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by philh on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:51PM (#10657336)
Again, you've turned "someone shouldn't be fired for bigotry" into "bigotry is okay". You've turned "someone shouldn't be fired for saying someone shouldn't be fired for bigotry" into "no one should ever be fired for anything".

As it happens, I'm okay with Donald Sterling being fired. I'm not okay with Josh Olin being fired for saying Donald Sterling shouldn't have been fired.

Would you support me being fired, for saying Josh Olin shouldn't have been fired?

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by JulianMorrison on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:32PM (#10657213)
It's not okay to say "bigotry is okay". It isn't. It's harmful. It has victims. The guy who got sacked, was rightfully sacked.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by talmand on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:49AM (#10655666)
Well, anecdotally, I often find that being used as an easy excuse to dismiss someone's concerns without having to address the concerns.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by CodeCube on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @09:57AM (#10663270)
What concerns exactly are you referring to?

If I hear someone expressing a view that I dislike, I'm well within my rights to do any or all of the following things: a) stop associating with this individual b) let them know that I dislike the view they've expressed.

Choosing to do both a) and b) is a normal social response, and the individual that finds themselves expressing views that go against the cultural majority will find themselves in an awkward position. If this view being expressed is worth expressing, then unfortunately the individual will have to endure hardships in order to get the message out and convince the masses ... much like MLKjr being willing to go to jail to communicate the idea that civil rights were for all.

So if someone wants to share racist jokes, then toughen up that skin and let the vitriol fly! They should be proud of what they are and let everyone know ... if it's a worthy viewpoint, they'll find others will rally to their cause; and if not, they'll find themselves awkwardly cast out by their social circle (or at least, their social circle's kids/younger generation).

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by pitay on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @08:07AM (#10662679)
I totally agree. I have had people blaming me for making them depressed when I was refuting someone saying 'you get out what was put into it', which I thought was complete bullshit the way he was saying it.

I was saying that a lot of success is due to chance, and that a lot of life events are due to chance. This got people some people saying that what I was saying was horribly depressing. The guy then proceeded to lecture me that my attitude was what was letting me down in something that I never did, and was irrelevant anyway. And that 'I may not have intended it, but that my actions are causing misery' (because I did apologize to people that saying that they were horribly depressed by me saying that life has chance in it, because I felt the need to be conciliatory).

That is what happened when I tried to be honest and disagree with someone spouting feel good bullshit or whatever else made him look good. A complete frigging cesspool.

Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by Anthony-G on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @01:03PM (#10664624)
That sounds like a tragic case of shooting the messenger. The sad outcome is that people learn to keep their mouths shut rather than tell unpalatable truths - and it's the whole group that loses out in the long fun.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by talmand on Wednesday December 02, 2015 @09:42AM (#10663165)
Don't apologize because of such nonsense, it only encourages the behavior.
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by jccalhoun on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:10AM (#10655386)
I teach cultural studies-related things and nearly all of my friends who are college profs are as well. I talk about race and gender regularly. The only non-grade related complaint I've ever gotten was that I used swear words in class - which would be hard not to do when one of the readings was about swearing...
Re:This Is Not a Day Care. It’s a University by 6stringmerc on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:58AM (#10655721)
I'm not trying to be glib but in my experience it's cutural studies mentalities applied to hard science courses (like biology for non-majors) or artistic roundtable formats (like creative writing workshops) where issues of race, gender, and feelings are inappropriately applied as 'arbiters' of "how" things are to be discussed. My apology if not totally clear, but the jist of what I'm getting at is my impression of cultural studies is that the inherent inclusiveness of 'perspectives' doesn't really challenge students, but predominately allows an arena for affirmation. I suppose what I mean is that based on the nature of the subject matter, an excellent rhetorical essay framing genocide of a certain culture can't really be criticized as 'bad thinking' if the structuring of the argument and included reasoning are sound, though the very concept itself is abhorrent in its premise.