It sounds like in your case, what made the idea good was not so much the product itself, but applying it to the right niche (product-market fit in modern startup parlance), possibly at the right time.
So maybe your idea wasn't so great after all?
I find it very common to hear people say "people made money off of my idea": that means people don't consider market timing or marketing to be part of the idea. Isn't that odd?
I guess that comes from "ideas" living on a spectrum from a vague "AirBnB for X" to a fully baked narrative that includes a very precise vision (not that that's what ends up being executed in the end). You hear a lot of the former, very few of the latter.
I have to date not been able to find a way to make the niche that I picked (one-to-many everybody is a broadcaster, think 'youtube', but live) into a mass market product (possibly because there is no mass market). Still, the idea lives on and periodically companies try to revive it in some way or other and some of those then find other successful niches.
"Improve compression technology X so that live video is technically feasible sooner than expected"...now that's a great idea. Likewise, "Use marketing technique Y to create an insatiable demand for personal web cams", also a great idea. Someone starting a company in a given space that think will take off doesn't really constitute a groundbreaking innovation, though it is a smart business move.
Many if not most people who say "I have great ideas all the time" are overvaluing the quality of their own thoughts. Plenty of people have good ideas every day. But truly great ideas, by definition, are rare. Not 1 in 100 rare. More like 1 in 1,000,000 rare. And it can be really hard to tell the difference between the two, especially when evaluating one's own ideas.
That's exactly what I did. But technology by itself does not make money, it needs packaging and marketing.
So such an idea is deceptively simple and it is the packaging of that idea in some concept that makes it valuable. Think of it as everybody in the world saying 'x' is impossible, and then you prove 'x' is indeed possible, and once that's proven there are many ways of capturing the value of that idea. Giving people the opportunity to be broadcasters was my way of trying to capture that value.
Great ideas and good ideas differ usually only by hindsight.
It depends on what you mean by a good idea. Do you have any ideas that tick 10 or more off my list?
Your list is interesting but it limits by virtue of being made from your perspective, I think it is an extremely interesting approach but it would need the merging of many such lists from many individuals before it would have real value. My 'best ideas' would not check 10 (or even 5) of your boxes and yet two of those turned into billion dollar industries and made some people extremely wealthy.
Not that I managed to capture much of that value :) Once again underlining that good ideas are not all that rare.
I'll see if I can come up with a list of my own that you can merge (if you agree with the criteria).
I did say the only critical requirement of a good idea is that you can execute it. By this criteria it sound like your good ideas were not so good :)
Then maybe you need better resources?
Having said this I do expect that a good list should share many points with my list. The major difference I think for many is likely to be over the importance or not of an idea being able to be bootstrapped. For many people this is not important, but for me it is very important.
I think you should add that caveat to your blog post! It makes all the difference and it makes me see your list in a much more favorable way.
So each and every one of those companies made mistakes, and most of them died. My little band of friends and me probably held on the longest but we also made plenty of mistakes but at least ours weren't of the fatal variety.
Even so, knowing it was a great idea and having all that knowledge and experience gained over those years I still would not know how we could have avoided the cap on our growth and how we could have staved off the inevitable.
Eventually lots of people made a ton of money of that same idea, with execution that rivaled or beat ours handily, or with a shift of focus to a different niche (there were 100's of those niches and some of those are super profitable).
If my team and me would have been better at the execution part, if we had been more business savvy we might have been able to lock up the market.
Great ideas I have every day, you can have them, I suspect that your ability to execute on average is about as good as mine or worse so I'm not too worried about competition in the earliest phase of an idea hitting the market. But once a market has been validated the parties that enter that appreciate the idea and that are good in execution, they'll go places.
Because you won't be able to keep your idea secret and hit the market at the same time, best case you'll be able to keep your idea secret until you hit the market, but when you do you had better be ready to lock up that market in a very short time otherwise you will just be another 'also ran'.
My story is one of a reasonably good team, reasonably good execution and a bunch of timing and other mishaps and a general problem of being 'green'. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the idea.
Good ideas have value: to the right team. Even bad ideas properly executed have value to the right team.
But good teams and excellent execution are far more rare than good ideas.