News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by foldr on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @01:49PM (#1065421)
Look, I'm not some lunatic who's saying that all women are equally attractive, or that partners never influence each other's dress. It's the tone of your post that I object to, but I can see this is lost on you. I doubt it will be lost on women that you date, though.

> No. It's ok to have standards.

Some standards are ok, some aren't. I'm not objecting to your having standards, just the particular standards that you appear to have.

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by lionhearted on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @02:13PM (#1065484)
Usually if someone slings mud, I'll just hang it up and call it the end of a discussion. But I think you're probably well-intentioned and a good person so I'll respond. Let's look at two statements here:

> It's the tone of your post that I object to, but I can see this is lost on you.

Your meaning wasn't lost on me. Earlier, you asked me, "Would you be okay with a girl you liked reading that?" And my answer is yes. Yes, I am not afraid to speak candidly to people in my life, women included. I usually have this exact same conversation with girls in my life - last night I was at Shilin Night Market with my new girlfriend here in Taipei, who is an athlete, and I told her that I think the Taiwanese men who want small, hyper-skinny, unathletic girls are crazy, and that I think those girls look very elegant, but are worse lovers and are less likely to give you strong children. This is completely not politically correct, but it's also honestly how I feel. And so if I speak on the topic, I wind up speaking candidly.

I understand occasionally someone will get upset, though it's clearly not the intention to upset people. Dating and sex and love is a very personal topic and can quite upset people by getting at them on an identity level.

So what's the answer? To speak in platitudes and generalities? There's no way to speak up candidly about dating, sex, love, men, and women without upsetting someone. You can't do it. So your choices are never speak up, or always say fuzzy things with many caveats in the most polite way - and never get your point across. I speak honestly. Hopefully my anecdote that started this thread will be of some value to people here, which is why I comment.

> I doubt it will be lost on women that you date, though.

Actually, you're right, but not in the way you mean. I've had some wonderful relationships in my life. I've probably been far more blessed than I deserve to be - but if you want to talk about relative social lives, sex lives, and dating lives, I'm happy to go there as you brought it up. We could compare and contrast, if you like, how your politically correct pseudo-chivalry is working vs. my slightly more gritty candidness. I would never have thought to bring such a thing up, it seems rather impolite, but I'll go there if you'd like to.

> I'm not objecting to your having standards, just the particular standards that you appear to have.

Snark aside, the great thing about being human is that you get to set your own standards. Mine work for me. Maybe you don't care so much about the things I care about? Totally okay! If you're happy with where you're at, and I'm happy where I'm at, life goes on.

If, however, you want to imply that political correctness and not being candid and having some sort of "acceptable standards" or some such will make you more effective at life or happier - well, this is where I must speak up and disagree.

No, I think you're probably a good person, and a thoughtful person, so I don't take any offense here. But I would encourage you to think - really think - about whether it's okay and acceptable for people to speak about what they truly want and go for out of life, even if it's not normally the most polite, even if it risks offending someone sensitive. Your answers might be different than mine - but mine came from a lot of life lessons, and my way generally serves me pretty well. Loosening off political correctness and sensitivity might do the same for you or others.

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by foldr on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @07:19PM (#1066216)
You seem to think that I am against people being candid, but I'm not. Don't assume that everyone secretly thinks what you think but is afraid to say so. I'm perfectly candid, I just don't share your views.

>Snark aside, the great thing about being human is that you get to set your own standards

And the great thing about writing about your standards on a public forum is that you get to hear other people's opinions on them, right?

>We could compare and contrast, if you like, how your politically correct pseudo-chivalry is working vs. my slightly more gritty candidness.

Actually I'm gay, so I'm afraid we can't compare our vaginal insemination success rates. But maybe we can lock horns? Or compare penis size? FWIW I do ok with other guys (and I generally allow them to dress themselves).

But if you just want to boast about your love/sex life, please don't feel that you need my cooperation. This is an open forum, after all.

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by yters on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @07:23PM (#1066229)
Be warned, it's possible to be a little too candid, as I found out recently. Or, at least don't let her mom find out about your candid comments.
Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by plinkplonk on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @02:17PM (#1065497)
Don't feed the troll.

(Who is voting this guy's blatherings about his sex life up? On HN!! Looks like some kind of voting ring)

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by ardit33 on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:40PM (#1065730)
lionhearted is not a troll. What he is saying it is actually resonated with what I think/do also.

BTW. My friends and I use the same term too. "Quality Woman": Is a girl/woman that is well educated, cute, nice, not with a huge self sense of entitlement, and a good personality.

Basically a woman that has her shit together, not bitchy, and is cute at the same time.

So instead of having a whole paragraph to describe her, just saying 'quality', and my friend will understand it immediately.

They are actually pretty rare in the US, especially single.

I don't know why, but European girls seem to be a lot balanced in general.

Maybe saying she is a great girl will be less offensive to few people? But whatever, life is short, so I am not going to live myself to appease everybody.

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by electromagnetic on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @07:53PM (#1066293)
Being from the UK, and having travelled Europe, the women aren't any different in any appreciable way. The only main difference between an 'American' girl and any other is the lower educational standard in the US. [Ed: However, with a smaller percentile of highly educated males, this shouldn't really be a major problem for the vast majority of people.]

I would also give a caveat, in continental Europe it's a more acceptable social norm for women to groom less. I'm not necessarily talking about the underarms (I've actually seen this less in Europe than I have elsewhere), but facial and leg hair. This can get bad with more southern-European where hair colour tends to be darker.

I groom my facial hair, and if I need to I groom my body hair (I have a mildly hairy back, which I personally dislike so it gets shaved) too. So I personally believe it's common courtesy for a woman to do it too.

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by foldr on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @07:27PM (#1066238)
>They are actually pretty rare in the US, especially single.

I think this is exactly the kind of attitude that some of us object to. Basically, a bunch of guys sitting around passing judgment on all the women in the world, concluding that hardly any of them are worthy of their (presumably much sought-after) affections.

For me, your explanation of what is meant by "quality" basically pushes all the buttons that the OP did.

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by plinkplonk on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:54PM (#1065758)
"lionhearted is not a troll. What he is saying it is actually resonated with what I think/do also."

A troll is as troll does. And this isn't about whether the two of you share some weird notion of "quality" in women. If you do, take it off line. This sexist claptrap doesn't belong on HN.

"I prefer taller women, and I prefer women who are built strong with good musculature, athletes, and girls with wider hips and shoulders."

Does anybody care a damn what someone's sexual preferences are like?

This is borderline locker room conversation - discussion of "long thin athletic" women, sexual history paraded as "education" for other readers, challenges to other people to compare their sexual lives with his (e.g:- "if you want to talk about relative social lives, sex lives, and dating lives, I'm happy to go there . We could compare and contrast, if you like, how your politically correct pseudo-chivalry is working vs. my slightly more gritty candidness")

Gritty candidness my foot! This sounds like juvenile frat boy crap to me.

It doesn't matter whether you have the same tastes.

I just happen to think such crudity should be kept off HN. If I am in the minority, so be it. Nothing prevents the lot of you from forming a private mailing list and exchanging vapid theories of "quality women".

Or are you saying your sexual fantasies and theories are of "intellectual interest to hackers"?

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by FooBarWidget on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @04:29PM (#1065841)
I am more disturbed by your accusation of the (grand)parent being sexist than by the contents of their posts. You kinda sound like someone who would accuse people of being "sexist" because they use the word "mankind" instead of "humankind".
Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by camccann on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:55PM (#1066487)
Fun fact: Did you know that the word "man" was originally sex-neutral? The generic term was co-opted for the specifically male sense centuries ago and the original masculine term mostly disappeared.

So, fight sexism by using "man" in the gender neutral sense! Reclaim the language!

(If you're wondering, the old terms were something like wer and wyf, prefixed to the generic "man". The latter obviously relates to "wife" and the compound wyfman shifted into the modern "woman". The compound werman disappeared, while the prefix remains only in terms like "werewolf", which is thus literally "man-wolf" in the distinctly masculine sense.)

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by enneff on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @05:34PM (#1065978)
"Does anybody care a damn what someone's sexual preferences are like?"

Who's the troll now? This discussion is clearly related to the article.

Re:The 4 Big Myths of Profile Pictures by FooBarWidget on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @04:26PM (#1065833)
I don't see how that's a troll. Seems like an intelligent comment to me.