News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is SystemVerilog the COBOL of Electronic Design? by PhantomGremlin on Monday November 30, 2015 @05:41PM (#10652433)
I'm still optimistic that FPGAs will gradually gather more software engineers into the fold

That would require a lot of retraining, at least that's my personal experience. Before I wrote any Verilog, I had a software background. I wrote lots of code in asm and C. I also did hardware board design and ASIC design (using schematic capture).

The problem is that Verilog tempts people with software experience into using techniques they're familiar with. E.g. some of my first Verilog looked like this (not proper syntax):

   if condition-expression1
      do something block
   else if condition-expression2
      do something block
   else if condition-expression3
      do something block
   else
      do something block
That's easy to understand software, but it synthesizes into horrible hardware. The problem is that the sequential tests are, necessarily, synthesized into a priority encoder. Which means that the comparison chain becomes a critical timing path. There are lots of traps like that which await software people.

Good hardware design requires a lot more parallelism than what software engineers are typically used to.

There are no comments on this comment yet.