Re:The envelope paradox (2006)
by StefanKarpinski on Monday November 30, 2015 @06:02PM
(#10652527)
Yeah, I'm not convinced anymore either. Specifically, I think that the assumption that R < A and A < B are independent events is incorrect, which means that P(R < A < B) = P(R < A)*P(A < B) is not necessarily true. I'll have to think on it more and maybe email Mark about it.
As long as A does not equal B with some positive probability, and as long as you choose a separator R with full support, then there is some probability that R lands between A and B. When that happens, you always win the game. Otherwise, if picking A or B randomly doesn't hurt you, then R landing somewhere else not between A and B doesn't hurt you either. So you've gotten a strategy that, once in a while, helps you separate A and B, and doesn't hurt you otherwise.