News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Is Getting More Bang for Its R&D Buck by cromwellian on Monday November 30, 2015 @03:38PM (#10651573)
I read this as "how Apple relies on the R&D of other companies" For example, the quote about how IBM spent 100x as much on R&D as Apple.

IBM has produced 6 Nobel prize winners that lead to revolutionary advancements in the industry which Apple "innovation" relies on. There would be no iPhone without the investments in basic research and process that has done been done at IBM, Bell Labs, Intel, et al. When I worked at IBM, I couldn't wait to read the next IBM Systems Journal, it was the only piece of "corporate" internal communications in any company I've ever worked for that I looked forward to. I worked at IBM T.J. Watson in the 90s and one of the things told to us during orientation is that our budget, and our research was separate and independent from the commercial divisions of IBM and we were free to work on stuff that wasn't necessarily commercially viable.

Something rubs me the wrong way about this article and Apple's R&D spending. R&D spending is wasteful, it is a gamble, but every once in a while, it produces something incredible that leads to a huge net positive externality for the world. Some of the greatest inventions were done on research no one ever thought would have any commercial usage. These days politicians decry studies on bear DNA, or Shrimps on Treadmills, but who's to say these won't be vitally important things 20 years from now?

Part of relying on the research advancements of others, standing on the shoulders of giants, IMHO, is to take your success and your profits, and invest them, continuing a kind of scientific "social contract" for those that come after you.

Hoarding profits and bragging about how you can get away with making lots of money without having to hire many researchers is IMHO, a kind of parasitical attitude.

On top of that, is the tendency of people to credit Apple for all advancements, even those that were tweaks on hard work done by others. Do I credit Apple for their graphics performance, or Microsoft, AMD, PowerVR, NVidia, SGI, and everyone else who over the past decade have invested massively into consumer 3D acceleration? Do I credit Apple for amazing battery improvements, or Intel or Samsung investments into NAND? Is the A9X more important than TSMC/Intel/Samsung fab innovations? Or IBM's introduction of STM, Magnetic Storage, Eximer Lasers?

Science and Innovation are social endeavors relying on a community of shared progress. The secretive way Apple does R&D, their lack of publishing, and the way they promote this 'lone genius/inventor' view of the company rubs me the wrong way. I'm not saying Apple hasn't innovated, especially in mobile software, but won't should brag about not doing basic research, and banking a hundred billion in offshore cash to be used for what, stock buybacks?

Just what is wrong with say, spending some of that money to fund research into say, quantum computing or medicine? Does every damn thing have to be applicable to the next iPhone?

Re:Apple Is Getting More Bang for Its R&D Buck by rarepostinlurkr on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:27AM (#10653800)
> Just what is wrong with say, spending some of that money to fund research into say, quantum computing or medicine? Does every damn thing have to be applicable to the next iPhone?

Things probably need a business plan backing them, which involves making money. Usually for social advancement we lobby the government to fund said research for our betterment. The private industry tends to fund research for its own betterment.

Also phrased another way, I imagine AAPL shareholders would be upset if Apple spent those profits on research into medicine, unless Apple was trying to build a product to sell said Medicine.

I think Society in general can benefit but it can be harder to see and the motives may often appear "after the fact", they may not have been an actual goal. Are people healthier due to health fitness trackers? Will doctors have better care due to the deluge of data? Can researchers actually get better data from cloud sourcing informatics, allowing their published work to happen faster or iterate on ideas quicker?

I wouldn't put a business plan on those goals, but I'll take them as a side effect for a gadget that everyone buys for whatever reason.

Re:Apple Is Getting More Bang for Its R&D Buck by phaus on Monday November 30, 2015 @04:02PM (#10651731)
>Shrimps on Treadmills

Serious question, meant with no sarcasm at all: Can you give an example of something as ridiculous as the shrimp on treadmills study that cost a fortune and ended up being incredibly important in a way that wasn't immediately obvious at the time the study was conducted?

Re:Apple Is Getting More Bang for Its R&D Buck by cromwellian on Monday November 30, 2015 @04:26PM (#10651941)
The shrimps on treadmills study didn't cost a fortune, that was ridiculous and dishonest conservative demogogueing over it with fictitious accounting.

It's like when a politician will say "This government project spent $1 billion to build a highway, and only produced 1000 jobs, at a cost of $1 million per job!" without looking at the other thing the project produced: a new highway!

The shrimp treadmill cost only $47 to make.(http://chronicle.com/blogs/conversation/2014/11/13/how-a-47-...) and was trying to figure out a way to determine food safety, you know, like whether the shrimp we're eating are diseased.

I'm pretty sure if you total up the money spent on number theorists over the past several decades, it all looked ridiculous numerical masturbation, up until the point where public key cryptography was invented.

By contrast, military R&D is HIDEOUSLY expensive by several orders of magnitude. The people whining about a $50 shrimp treadmill need to get their fucking head in order and look at the cost of the F-35.

Re:Apple Is Getting More Bang for Its R&D Buck by phaus on Monday November 30, 2015 @07:12PM (#10652847)
Thanks for answering. Now it makes a lot more sense. I wasn't aware of the follow-up articles, only the original politically-fused exaggerations.
Re:Apple Is Getting More Bang for Its R&D Buck by maxxxxx on Monday November 30, 2015 @04:44PM (#10652112)
There was a time when X-rays were considered useless or nuclear physics. In addition, if you took a closer look at a shrimp on treadmills study and its rationale, you would often see the use pretty quickly.
Re:Apple Is Getting More Bang for Its R&D Buck by sedachv on Monday November 30, 2015 @05:53PM (#10652487)
The British government gave Charles Babbage the 1830s equivalent of 2.4 million USD to come up with a more efficient way of making printed logarithmic tables, which Babbage never managed to accomplish.