I am not dismissive towards Coq (how can anyone be?), and my advice is neither less solicited nor less relevant than many other HN comments.
But you are right that I sometimes try to correct what I see as a (strange) imbalance here on HN (which reflects neither the prevailing opinions in academia nor in the industry) regarding PFP and type theory. People unfamiliar with the topic might get the impression that PFP+type-theory is either the only or the most prevalent technique for software verification (or software correctness in general), while neither is the case. In exchange, I get to be the lucky target of various ad hominem attacks, so I guess I've earned my right to speak up :)
Re:The C standard formalized in Coq
by throwaway999888 on Monday November 30, 2015 @12:50PM
(#10650667)
The phrase "ad hominem" has become really watered-out.
Re:The C standard formalized in Coq
by nickpsecurity on Monday November 30, 2015 @12:19PM
(#10650508)
I noticed along with no supporting evidence presented in relevancy for this topic. Hence my comment. ;)
pron has this habit of being negative and dismissive towards functional programming and related things, recommending non-FP alternatives instead. Which is fine, only that sometimes he's too trigger happy and just gives unsolicited advice without any build up or with weak topical relevance. Like here.