Re:The envelope paradox (2006)
by umanwizard on Monday November 30, 2015 @12:32PM
(#10650582)
"Can't rule out the possibility" isn't the same thing as "nonzero probability".
E.g. pick a number uniformly at random between 0 and 1. It might be rational, but the probability of that is 0.
You're moving the goalposts from what the article claims.
The opponent's strategy is unknown and unspecified, per the puzzle. The point of the article is that there is a strategy that never does worse than chance, and may do better, depending on the opponent's choice of numbers. Sure, the opponent can make your advantage arbitrarily small - the article says that directly. But the notion that they are trying to do so is not part of the puzzle, and finding a strategy that prevents them from doing so is not what the author claims to have done.
As the puzzle and strategy are stated, the methods for choosing A/B/R are all left unspecified. If we don't know how they're chosen, it stands to reason that we can't rule out the possibility of R falling between A and B, hence there's a nonzero chance of it happening. If you want a rigorous way to show this even for any given opponent strategy, the player can choose R from an unbounded distribution - which is nonzero everywhere, and therefore nonzero between A and B, for any choices of A!=B.