News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The envelope paradox (2006) by alister on Monday November 30, 2015 @05:15AM (#10648678)
You have an interesting thought and I was wondering the same thing.

OP says that the probability of winning in the 3 cases are:

(1) 50% win, (2) 50% win, (3) always win

If I understand correctly, you're saying that the probabilities might perhaps be:

(1) 50% win minus some probability of case 3 happening, (2) 50% win minus some probability of case 3 happening, (3) always win

Then the three cases even out to 50% and there is no winning strategy.

But wouldn't your argument break down where you write, "But the interval less than X is finite, while the interval above X is infinite."? Since we're dealing with reals, then both (+∞, X) and (X, R) have an equally large and infinite set of numbers (i.e., the latter is not a finite set)[1]. So, Y is as likely to be found in (+∞, X) as in (X, R).

I'm still wondering if there's a way to make your argument work.

[1] https://proofwiki.org/wiki/Closed_Interval_in_Reals_is_Uncou...

Re:The envelope paradox (2006) by jdmichal on Monday November 30, 2015 @08:30AM (#10649243)
> But wouldn't your argument break down where you write, "But the interval less than X is finite, while the interval above X is infinite."? Since we're dealing with reals, then both (+∞, X) and (X, R) have an equally large and infinite set of numbers (i.e., the latter is not a finite set)[1]. So, Y is as likely to be found in (+∞, X) as in (X, R).

Yes, of course. I realized this about 5 minutes ago in the shower and was hoping no one had called me out on it yet!

I think the real argument is actually a combination of this and landryraccoon's post, depending on the problem definition. [1] The problem is either defined in such a way that the (X, R) interval is finite, and therefore falls under my argument. -OR- the problem defines (X, R) to be infinite, and P(case 3) is zero.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10647331