Re:Why you should start a company in… New York
by btilly on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:52AM
(#1064834)
I have more than anecdotal evidence, but it isn't in an online form.
Detailed discussions with a good lawyer about NY state law is that there are three classes of employee. Those are contractors, hourly, and professional. If you are not working by the project and don't have to track your time on a clock, then you are a professional employee. By default any work done by a professional employee which relates to that employee's job function belongs to the employer. (If a programmer writes a novel, the novel is probably his. But a program written is probably not his.) It is standard and customary for employers to add clauses to contracts reiterating that principle. This makes their case even stronger.
And yes, I've been personally caught on the wrong side of this. And yes, I personally know other people in an unrelated incident whose startup folded in exactly this manner.
OTOH if your contract has clauses protecting you then you are likely protected from this. However the common default is otherwise.
By contrast in California state law work done on your own time with your own equipment which does not use your employer's intellectual property is never a work for hire. This right cannot be signed away. The result is that your startup on the side is always legally protected.
And yes. This is among the reasons that I now live in California, and not NY.
Re:Why you should start a company in… New York
by borism on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:26PM
(#1065687)
There are so many ways I see to bypass this (pseudo)problem starting with (techno)logical and ending with legal solutions, I don't see how it matters at all.
Detailed discussions with a good lawyer about NY state law is that there are three classes of employee. Those are contractors, hourly, and professional. If you are not working by the project and don't have to track your time on a clock, then you are a professional employee. By default any work done by a professional employee which relates to that employee's job function belongs to the employer. (If a programmer writes a novel, the novel is probably his. But a program written is probably not his.) It is standard and customary for employers to add clauses to contracts reiterating that principle. This makes their case even stronger.
And yes, I've been personally caught on the wrong side of this. And yes, I personally know other people in an unrelated incident whose startup folded in exactly this manner.
OTOH if your contract has clauses protecting you then you are likely protected from this. However the common default is otherwise.
By contrast in California state law work done on your own time with your own equipment which does not use your employer's intellectual property is never a work for hire. This right cannot be signed away. The result is that your startup on the side is always legally protected.
And yes. This is among the reasons that I now live in California, and not NY.