Re:The envelope paradox (2006)
by logicallee on Sunday November 29, 2015 @11:55PM
(#10647797)
(edited) In my analogy, assessing the universe numerically = opening the envelope to see what number is inside. I think it's a pretty close analogy, and obviously leads to an absurd, nonsensical result: that we can learn something about whether we 'probably' (>50%) are in the better universe, without knowing anything about the value of the other one.
I still don't see why your analogy does anything but introduce additional complication. To me, the result appears no more nonsensical than in the original formulation - where it appears correct. So long as X and Y are chosen in advance - and independently - of my guessing, if I draw my reference R from any continuous distribution, there is some nonzero chance that it will fall between X and Y, letting me distinguish them in that case.
Re:The envelope paradox (2006)
by logicallee on Monday November 30, 2015 @06:06AM
(#10648808)
you have no idea what possible values X and Y can have. It's like an alternative universe, or guessing a number first and then finding a function to numerically evaluate the universe whose range you don't know in advance. I find it nonsensical that this can yield any information.
No, per the article you'll have a marginally better chance than picking without assessing at all. I don't think your framing shows anything at all about whether that's sense or nonsense.