Anyway, I fully agree that having your comments auto-killed just for saying what you think - no matter how unpopular - should never happen.
Is it possible that there is some kind of low threshold for your karma after which all your comments get killed?
Because I'm fairly sure that I have said some pretty unpopular stuff here and afaik I am not dead.
Maybe it's not too smart to start antagonizing people right off the bat, before you have sufficient 'karma cushion' to survive a drive-by downmod or two.
How about only displaying the downmod button after you've answered someone?
It is weird that the "new" social news sites mess up moderation so badly. Slashdot solved this years ago; I never see spam on Slashdot. Nor do I see people being auto-killed there.
View the firehose at 'black' level and you'll see more spam than on hn, just a random sample:
http://slashdot.org/firehose.pl?op=view&id=8811130&a...
The firehose is equivalent to the HN 'new' page.
If you only look at the homepage on HN you will never see spam.
It seems like the idea is to encourage the usual social-news-site groupthink, even though pg has publicly stated that he wants to avoid this. (The spaghetti-code that is news.arc is probably a contributing factor, but I digress...)