News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why was a comment I made killed? by shrughes on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @08:11AM (#1064664)
What are you talking about, this isn't a question of security.
Re:Ask HN: Why was a comment I made killed? by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @08:32AM (#1064694)
It's a metaphor. The excuse I keep hearing is that if we learn how HN filters spam, it will enable spammers to game the system.

Frankly, I don't care so much about the internal mechanisms used to kill posts. I just want to understand the policy; I have the showdead flag on and at least a quarter of the time, I can't for the life of me figure out why a comment was killed. That lack of transparency makes me uncomfortable.

Re:Ask HN: Why was a comment I made killed? by jacquesm on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @08:37AM (#1064704)
That's PG's own view of how this works, we're not even supposed to tell people to stop bothering with their posts because they have been banned.

I can see the rationale for it at some level but I really doubt that it has much effect, spammers are pretty good at monitoring the effect of their actions.

It also makes me wonder who the mysterious 'you've been banned' emailer is.

Re:Ask HN: Why was a comment I made killed? by shrughes on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @08:59AM (#1064735)
I don't think the lack-of-telling-people-to-not-bother-posting is about spam, it's about ordinary internet rats who would just reregister and continue making terrible posts.

It also makes me wonder who the mysterious 'you've been banned' emailer is.

What? I've never heard about this. (Edit: Oh, I glossed over half the threadstarter's text.)

Re:Ask HN: Why was a comment I made killed? by jacquesm on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:02AM (#1064737)
> I don't think the lack-of-telling-people-to-not-bother-posting is about spam, it's about ordinary internet rats who would just reregister and continue making terrible posts.

That's very well possible.

(edit: I doubt someone would go out of their way to alert a troll to being banned though)

> What? I've never heard about this.

You would have if you read the posting at the top of the page ;)

Re:Ask HN: Why was a comment I made killed? by Freebytes on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:54AM (#1064843)
It is possible for someone to make poor posts in the beginning and improve their post content when they realize their role within the community. Many new visitors to HN are likely to encounter this by simply making a one-line 'witty' comment that people dislike. When that gets downvoted, they may tend to lean towards more informative and relevant posts after learning their lesson.