It's interesting to hear that you can actually make it look good, as it's always looked very plain-vanilla to me. Making it do fancy things would be nice too, but I honestly don't have the time anymore.
Update: I checked out reddit.com/r/unixporn/ and was not particularly impressed. Sure, those screenshots look better than stock i3, but really nothing compared to enlightenment even as far back as the 90's.
All i3 itself has to offer are either a blocky, rectangular titlebar or no titlebar, with the windows themselves having a variable width border, with the colors of both the titlebar and border adjustable. That's about it. The rest of the screenshots just show various window/root backgrounds and transparent windows. It looks ok, but I wouldn't call it "porn".
That said, i3 is still great. Even stock i3 has been good enough for me, and like I said, I use it for reasons other than eyecandy.
Oh, i see some folks have forked their own version of i3 (i.e. i3-gaps) to add additional features for modding.
I think i3 should remain true to it's initial vision (i3 is primarily targeted at advanced users and developers.)
That's not the i3 I know.
I never really used it for that reason, I was just pointing out something that's popular among younger linux fans on other parts of the web.
Recently I switched from i3 to bspwm, I really love the approach bspwm takes. Definitely the best designed window manager I've used.
Also it's much more configurable and has useless gaps by default (personal preference).
Beginners might learn vim to modify their ~/.i3/config, hex values for coloring their desktop, or basic CLI commands to add functionality to their keybindings. Maybe they want to add a customized weather applet to the bar at the bottom of the screen, so they write a shell script utilizing wget. Soon enough they're learning to install Arch Linux (because everybody else on that "Show off your desktop" thread is using it), and it's not long before they're a full-blown linux fanboy. That's at least the route I took.
It's not that i3 is popular among these communities because it's the easiest, but because it looks the coolest and offers the most amount of visual customization. But after getting used to it, there's an incredible amount of depth and usability that keeps you on it. I really can't imagine a more effective window manager.
If you're looking for neat-looking i3 setups, check out reddit.com/r/unixporn/ . If you're interested in getting started with it, somebody made a great tutorial for it at youtube.com/watch?v=j1I63wGcvU4 .